Online journal (www.statoechiese.it)
Online from january 2007
Menu

Articoli in

La delibazione delle sentenze di nullità matrimoniale: orientamenti giurisprudenziali e nuove questioni - ​ Marco Canonico

SOMMARIO: 1. Il riconoscimento delle nullità matrimoniali canoniche nel Concordato lateranense - 2. L’efficacia civile delle sentenze ecclesiastiche di nullità matrimoniale nell’Accordo di Villa Madama - 3. Il requisito del mancato contrasto con l’ordine pubblico e l’evoluzione giurisprudenziale in materia: l’introduzione del criterio della buona fede - 4. La distinzione tra incompatibilità assolute e relative - 5. La rilevanza attribuita alla prolungata convivenza coniugale - 6. Le nuove questioni - 7. Considerazioni conclusive.

The exequatur of the judgments of nullity of marriage: jurisprudential orienttions and new issues

ABSTRACT: The study examines the exequatur of the judgments of nullity of marriage, highlighting the orientations of the jurisprudence and the new issues posed by the doctrine in the light of the reform of the canonical marriage process.

Download in PDF format

“More sinned against than sinning”: la Corte Suprema pakistana e il caso Asia Bibi - ​ Deborah Scolart

SOMMARIO: 1. Premessa - 2. La blasphemy law - 3. Un campo di falsa, un sorso d’acqua e il “peccato” contro Asia Bibi - 4. La sentenza della Corte Suprema - 5. Leading case o moral suasion?

“More sinned against than sinning”:  the Pakistan Supreme Court and Asia Bibi case

ABSTRACT:  Asia Bibi case, a Christian woman falsely accused of being a blasphemer, finds her ‘judge in Berlin’ in the Supreme Court of Pakistan. The Court does not address the ratio legis of blasphemy law but points out how contrary to the spirit of Islam is the misuse of law for political purposes. The wide international echo of the case makes this SC verdict a possible leading case in theme of presumption of innocence.

Download in PDF format

La Chiesa Ortodossa Russa e le riforme dell’inizio del XX secolo - ​ Giovanni Codevilla

SOMMARIO: 1. La riforma di Pietro il Grande e la paralisi della Chiesa - 2. La diffusa aspirazione a ridefinire i rapporti tra Stato e Chiesa - 3. Verso il superamento dell’intolleranza religiosa - 4. Le prese di posizione di Antonij (Vadkovskij) e di Sergej Witte - 5. La reazione del Pobedonoscev – 6. Il Memorandum dei 32 - 7. Il riconoscimento della tolleranza religiosa - 8. I vescovi e la riforma ecclesiastica - 9. Il Manifesto del 17 ottobre e i ritardi nella convocazione del Concilio.

The Russian Orthodox Church at the Beginning of the 20th Century

ABSTRACT: Peter the Great abolished the Patriarchate and entrusted the direction of the Church to a Holy Synod led by a laymen (Ober-prokuror). This reform had the consequence to paralyze the Church, as pointed out by F.M. Dostoevskij and by several outstanding Russian scholars. At the end of the 19th and at the beginning of the 20th century the necessity to overcome the relationship of subjection of the Church to the State was clearly perceived both by the intellectuals and inside the Church. The Tsar himself realized that there was a need of a change: the Fundamental laws were consequently modified and religious tolerance was acknowledged on April 17th 1905. Of paramount importance was the role played by the Prime-minister Sergej Witte and by the Metropolitan of St. Petersburg Antonij (Vadkovskij) to overcome the conservative ecclesiastical policy carried out by the Ober-prokuror Konstantin Pobedonoscev. The answers given by the bishops to a questionnaire issued by the Holy Synod on July 27th, 1905, confirmed that the problem was clearly felt also inside the Church. The Council of the Russian Church, which was supposed to be gathered at the beginning of the century, was summoned several years later, at the eve of the bolshevik coup d’état.

Download in PDF format

La questione della liceità della circoncisione “rituale” tra tutela dell’identità religiosa del gruppo e salvaguardia del diritto individuale alla integrità fisica - ​ Angelo Licastro

SOMMARIO: 1. Notazioni introduttive - 2. La circoncisione “terapeutica” e quella “profilattica” - 3. La circoncisione “tradizionale” e quella (propriamente) “rituale” - 4. L’orientamento che giudica la pratica contraria ai diritti fondamentali del minore - 5. La circoncisione rituale ebraica e la legge 8 marzo 1989, n. 101 - 6. La circoncisione rituale tra libertà religiosa, diritto alla salute e diritto all’integrità fisica - 7. Osservazioni conclusive.

The issue of lawfulness of “ritual” circumcision: protection of collective religious identity versus violation of individual’s right to physical integrity

ABSTRACT: The present essay deals with the issue regarding the lawfulness of male “ritual” circumcision, that is performed for non-therapeutic reasons. Female genital mutilation (FGM) is considered as a violation of human rights in the Western world; on the contrary, male circumcision for non-therapeutic reasons is currently tolerated. However, in many Countries experts hightlighted the permanent effect of circumcision on bodily integrity and the special importance of the right to self-determination. The Author stresses problems that the circumcision poses in the Italian legal system, considering special legislation related to Jewis (law No. 101/1989) and case law that assesses the practice lawful in case it is performed with the parents’ consent and according to the rules of medical art.

Download in PDF format

Etica e pastorale in Attilio Nicora - ​ Carlo Cardia

SOMMARIO: 1. La personalità di Attilio Nicora, negoziatore, diplomatico, uomo di fede - 2. La formazione culturale, il rigore del metodo, la matrice montiniana - 3. Le lezioni della storia, la laicità, i rapporti tra Stato e Chiesa - 4. Volontà riformatrice, il coraggio dell’innovazione - 5. Le qualità del diplomatico, le sofferenze del Pastore - 6. Le virtù di Attilio Nicora, la sua eredità spirituale e culturale.

Download in PDF format

Educación, proselitismo y adoctrinamiento: perfil y repercusiones jurídicas - ​ José Mª Martí Sánchez

SUMARIO: 1. Introducción - 2. El concepto de educación-enseñanza, vinculado a la libertad religiosa y el pluralismo - 3. El proselitismo o incitación articulada para compartir una opción de vida - 4. El concepto de adoctrinamiento, como conducta lícita e ilícita - 5. Consecuencias jurídicas: la educación y sus parámetros - 6. Consecuencias jurídicas: El proselitismo legítimo y el abusivo o ilícito - 7. Los conflictos del proselitismo en el seno de la familia, según el TEDH - 8. Consecuencias jurídicas: el “adoctrinamiento” en la educación familiar y reglada - 9. El adoctrinamiento en los tipos penales - 10. Conclusiones.

Education, proselytism and indoctrination: profile and legal treatment

ABSTRACT: Nowadays the identity is a big question, and his preservation depends by a great deal on the education, the proselytism and the indoctrination. These three concepts, close and complex, demand a juridical explanation. This study looks for to light up them, in the European and Spanish context, through the legislation and the case-law.

Download in PDF format

Vulnerabilità, morte e pietas. L’atto della sepoltura e le sue implicazioni giuridiche - ​ Serena Vantin

SOMMARIO: 1. Una chiarificazione concettuale - 2. Vulnerabilità e diritto - 3. L’atto della sepoltura - 4. Il diritto alla sepoltura - 5. Conclusioni.

Vulnerability, Death and Pietas. The Act of Burial and its Legal Implications

ABSTRACT: This paper offers a conceptual clarification of the concept “vulnerability”, focusing in particular on the legal meanings it has recently assumed. Considering the cultural legacy relative to the act of burial, the reflection will also lead to put at stake, through the vulnerability’s perspective, the need for a harmonization and an updating of the legislation referred to cemeteries and sepulchres.

Download in PDF format

The Children Act: alla ricerca del “superiore interesse del minore” tra famiglie, comunità religiose e giudici - ​ Silvia Angeletti

SOMMARIO: 1. Introduzione - 2. Primo Movimento: Il minore nel contesto familiare e nel gruppo religioso - 3. Secondo Movimento: Il ruolo del giudice, tra autodeterminazione in materia sanitaria e best interests of the child - 4. Terzo Movimento: Conclusioni. L’evoluzione del minore in una società plurale.

The Children Act: Finding the best interests of the child between family, religious community and the court

ABSTRACT: Connections that bring together law and literature unceasingly prove to be very meaningful. Ian McEwan’s novel, The Children Act, offers an intriguing example of law in literature, cannily managing the complex theme of religion and justice. A young Jehovah’s Witness affected by a severe disease refuses to have his life saved by a blood transfusion. The Family Court finds in favour of the medical treatment against the child and his family’s convictions but the ruling triggers an unpredictable chain of events culminating in a tragic epilogue. Similarities between the novel and real law cases about refusals of medical treatments on religious grounds are traced throughout the article, which aims at analysing the controversial relations among the subjects and interests involved when dealing with a child medical consent and conscientious objections, mainly the duties of the family, the rights of the child and the responsibilities of the state. Concluding remarks will highlight that, in order for the child to express an autonomous and informed consent, a thorough and critical education is needed, provided through a pluralistic learning environment and an inclusive social framework, as international bodies - like the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child - clearly suggest.

Download in PDF format

Libertà di religione e spazi per il culto tra consolidate tutele e nuove comunità religiose - ​ Paolo Cavana

SOMMARIO: 1. Pluralismo religioso e luoghi di culto - 2. Gli edifici di culto nell’ordinamento italiano - 2.1. La normativa unilaterale statale: una tutela plurifunzionale - 2.2. La normativa pattizia, tra garanzia e promozione degli interessi religiosi - 2.3. La legislazione urbanistica e antisismica - 2.4. Apertura e finanziamento degli edifici di culto - 3. I luoghi di culto delle confessioni religiose prive di intesa - 4. La questione dei luoghi di culto islamici - 5. Osservazioni conclusive.

Religious freedom and places of worship in Italian Law

ABSTRACT: This paper deals with the complex legal framework and major issues concerning the churches and other places of worship in Italian legislation, which aims to protect an extraordinary historical and artistic heritage but, in the same time, is marked by an increasing inadequacy in order to meet the needs of new religious communities.

Download in PDF format

Sur le film “Matilda“ dans le contexte de la protection de la dignité des croyants - ​ Igor V. Ponkin Victor I. Slobodtchikov Vsevolode Yu. Troytskiy Alexandre Yu. Evdokimov

SOMMAIRE: 1. Introduction - 2. Méthodes appliquées dans la recherche et le domaine de la réalité objective et analytique; objet de la recherche - 3. Recherche dans le cadre de la réponse à la question № 1 - 4. Recherche dans le cadre de la réponse à la question № 2 - 4.1. Recherche et l’appréciation de l’image formée et retransmise par le film “Matilda“ de l’Empereur de Russie Nicolas II (Romanov) canonisé par l’Eglise Orthodoxe Russe - 4.2. Recherche et l’appréciation de l’image formée et retransmise par le film “Matilda“ de l’épouse de l’Empereur Nicolas II, Alexandre Féodorovna, canonisée par l’Eglise Orthodoxe Russe - 5. Recherche dans le cadre de la réponse à la question № 3 - 6. Recherche dans le cadre de la réponse à la Question № 4.

About the film “Matilda” in the context of protecting the dignity of believers

ABSTRACT: In 2017, the film «Matilda» caused a strong controversy in Russia. This article is devoted to the study of this film. The authors explore the film in the context of protecting the human dignity and the rights of believers, protecting their religious feelings. Critics of the film "Matilda" indicated that this film represents mockingly offensive images of those persons who are religiously revered by Orthodox Christian believers. The authors of the article check the validity of such critical assessments.

Download in PDF format

Le proiezioni collettive della libertà religiosa - ​ Antonio Fuccillo

SOMMARIO: 1. Le proiezioni delle religioni nei rapporti giuridici collettivi - 2. “La dimensione collettiva dell’esperienza religiosa e teorizzazione giuridica costituzionale (1948-2018)” - 3. “Autonomia della ‘confessione’ islamica e neo-giurisdizionalismo. ‘Crisi’ della laicità? Le risorse della laicità come pluralismo confessionale e ‘culturale’” - 4. “La definizione della nozione di Confessione religiosa nel prisma della giurisprudenza: un’analisi dell’ordinamento giuridico italiano” - 5. “La funzione nomopoietica dell’art. 20 della Carta Costituzionale” - 6. “Autonomia confessionale e sistema delle fonti del diritto ecclesiastico. Riforma del Terzo settore e tutela della privacy: un banco di prova per la produzione normativa confessionale” 7. “Ambiente, creato, sviluppo umano integrale. Dimensione religiosa collettiva e prospettiva ecologica” - 8. “La tutela dei luoghi sacri naturali: valori spirituali e patrimonio bioculturale nell’ordinamento giuridico italiano” - 9. “Proselitismo porta a porta, attività organizzativa delle confessioni religiose e norme europee sulla tutela della privacy” - 10. ... Per una riflessione!

The collective projections of religious freedom

ABSTRACT: This paper investigates new perspectives on religious freedom in Italy. Many issues on religious freedom are on environment protection, religious organizations, heritage on holy places and privacy protection. Especially, the focus is real dimension on relationship between State and churches in the Constitutional statement of Italian Republic.

Download in PDF format

Amministrazione pubblica e diritti fondamentali - ​ Anna Romeo

SOMMARIO: 1. Libertà e diritti fondamentali - 2. Amministrazione e diritto alla salute - 3. Amministrazione e diritto all'unità familiare, all'istruzione e alle prestazioni sociali - 4. Amministrazione e diritto di proprietà - 5. Per una effettività dei diritti fondamentali attraverso l'amministrazione.

Public Administration and Fundamental Rights

ABSTRACT: Moving from a brief historical reconstruction, the present contribution examines the theme of fundamental rights, focusing in particular on those that are ultimately the subject of profound debate, such as the right to health, especially due to the implications it presents with other highly discussed issues such as, for example, the end-of-life, as well as the right to family unity, with particular reference to foreigners. He also pauses to analyze more traditional fundamental rights such as the right to property and the right to education.

Download in PDF format

Il delicato bilanciamento costituzionale fra libertà di parola e tutela del sentimento religioso: profili comparati - ​ Stefano Testa Bappenheim

SOMMARIO: 1. Premessa - 2. Il quadro costituzionale in Pakistan - 3. La tutela del sentimento religioso nel codice penale pakistano - 4. Il quadro costituzionale tedesco - 5. La tutela del sentimento religioso nel codice penale tedesco - 6. Conclusioni.

The delicate constitutional Balance between Freedom of Speech and the Protection of religious Sentiment: comparative Profiles

ABSTRACT: The article focuses on the issue of freedom of speech and freedom of religion from the point of view of two countries with specific legislation in place (Pakistan and Germany). In particular, we will examine the two Constitutions and the two Criminal Law, which proved to have very different ways of expressing their sensitivity and a great attention to the religious sentiment of the population.

Download in PDF format

Religione e guarigione: libertà religiosa e principio di autodeterminazione in materia di salute mentale (salus aegroti suprema lex o voluntas aegroti suprema lex) - ​ Cristiana Maria Pettinato

SOMMARIO: 1. Linee di lettura - 2. La guarigione forzata: i fatti di Vilnius - 3. Il percorso giudiziario che conduce alla decisione di Strasburgo - 4. La dissenting opinion: brevi appunti sul metodo -5. Il sofferto cammino della libertà religiosa tra fede, stregoneria e follia - 6. La forza terapeutica della libertà religiosa: “capacità-libertà” di credere e diritto di guarire - 7. La funzione politica della religione in terra lituana: semi di neo-confessionismo - 8. La sfida dell’inclusione dell’altro da sé: scelte etero-spirituali e prudentia iuris.

Religion and healing: religious freedom and the principle of self-determination in matters of mental health (Salus aegroti suprema lex o voluntas aegroti suprema

ABSTRACT: The case before the Court of Strasbourg, projects us into the most sacred and private dimension of the life of the human being: that of religious options. In the present case, a young woman with behavioral disorders, manifested even before joining the group close to the Movement founded by the Indian Master Osho, following undergoes a series of medical treatments obligatory that force her to the suspension of the religious practices to which she usually devotes for her own psychophysical well-being. But according to the opinion of the doctors these practices compromised the applicant's mental health status, representing a serious and ascertained danger. The doctor becoming the promoter of his patient's health, ends up interfering in the personal sphere of the girl's religious sentiment, trying to modify the choices deemed to be non-conforming to tradition and prejudicial to health, without scientific evidence and, exclusively, on basis of presumptions and religious prejudices. The facts give rise to some considerations on the methods and criteria for balancing the protection of the right to health, and self-determination in therapeutic choices, and the exercise of religious freedom in conditions of compromised mental health, and the risk of a reviving confessional in Lithuania.

Download in PDF format

Le libre exercice du culte dans la République populaire de Chine - ​ Andrea Tigrino

SOMMAIRE: 1. Une prémisse historique sur la Chine en tant que société multi-religieuse - 2. Les dispositions constitutionnelles relatives à la liberté de croyance avant 1982 - 3. La liberté religieuse dans l'actuelle Constitution de 1982 et la législation suivant en la matière - 4. Liberté religieuse et protection des droits de l'homme dans la Chine actuelle.

The free exercise of Religion in People’s Republic of China

ABSTRACT: After some historical reflections on the spread of multiple religious doctrines on the Chinese territory between the end of the XIX and the beginning of the XX century, the Author considers the attitude of the central government with respect to the right of religious freedom from the time of the Cultural Revolution to today, paying particular attention to the constitutional and criminal law provisions attached to this issue. It seems clear how the Chinese legal tradition is not based on a balance of interest theory as known in the Western legal systems, given the prevalence of the higher communist principles rooted in time. Last pages are reserved for the systematic violations of human rights reported by numerous international observatories, as well as the ancient grudge between China and the Holy See caused by the question of the appointment and formal recognition of new bishops. The provisional agreement signed on 22 September 2018, while marking a step towards finding a solution to this tensions, doesn’t offer a definitive solution to the problem.

Download in PDF format

Religious hate speech, libertà di religione e libertà di espressione. Intersezioni tra forma e sostanza dei diritti nella società multiculturale - ​ Cristiana Cianitto

SOMMARIO: 1. Premesse - 2. Un possibile modello alternativo di tutela: la forma della tutela - 3. Un possibile modello alternativo di tutela: la sostanza della tutela - 4. Alcuni casi pratici - 4.1. Il leader politico - 4.2. Il leader religioso - 5. Conclusioni.

Religious hate speech, freedom of religion and freedom of expression. Reshaping the rights in the multicultural societies

ABSTRACT: In the multicultural societies, lawyers are more and more often engaged in identifing useful tools to solve the rising conflicts between fundamental rights. The exercise of freedom of religion and freedom of expression can led into this kind of phenomena that could be taken into consideration by law, like hate speech and religious hate speech. The paper tries to approach two particular form of hate speech, the political and the religious one, to check if some alternative models of protection could be implemented to assure an effective protection of minorities without any sacrifice of individual fundamental rights.

Download in PDF format

L’assetto giuridico delle comunità israelitiche italiane nel primo decennio post-unitario - ​ Stefania Dazzetti

SOMMARIO: 1. Premessa - 2. Il congresso israelitico di Ferrara (1863) - 3. Il disegno di legge Vacca del 1865 - 4. Il congresso israelitico di Firenze (1867) - 5. Conclusioni.

The legal framework of the italian Jewish communities in the first decade of Italy’s unification

ABSTRACT: The essay deals with the unification of the normative structures of the Italian Jewish communities after the Unity, by reconstructing the extensive debate that took place in the Jewish context. It then analyzes the legislative proposal of extending Rattazzi's law of 1857 to the entire national territory, which was presented by the Italian government to the Parliament in 1865. Finally, it gives an account, through a vast and largely unpublished archival documentation, both of the choice of individual communities to maintain the legal systems in force in the pre-unitary italian States, and of the attempts, advanced in the parliamentary center between the end of the nineteenth and the beginning of the twentieth century, of abrogation of the Rattazzi's law, considered, due to its jurisdictional traits, in contrast to the principles of the liberal State.

Download in PDF format

Quo vadis. Narrazione del tempo di Nerone. Ovvero la potenza delle parole - ​ Francesco Alicino

SOMMARIO: 1. Preambolo - 2. La potenza delle parole - 3. La forza di un sentimento - 4. Inventarsi la verità - 5. La desacralizzazione di Dio - 6. La sacralizzazione dell’uomo - 7. Epilogo.

Quo Vadis: A Narrative of the Time of Nero. The Power of the Words

ABSTRACT: Set during the reign of the emperor Nero, Quo Vadis tells the story of the love that develops between a young Christian woman and a Roman officer who, after meeting her fellow Christians, converts to her religion. Underlying their relationship, the novel becomes a good stratagem to emphasize the contrast between the worldly opulence of the Roman Empire and the poverty and spiritual power of the Christians, whose concepts would play a crucial role during the long history of the Western Legal System. With this paper the Author tries to explain how important a novel like Quo Vadis could be in order to better understand the strong impact of the Christian tradition on the history of Western constitutionalism.

Download in PDF format

Profili del sacro all’interno dei sistemi giuridici c.d. “plurali”. Recenti tendenze nell’ordinamento costituzionale canadese - ​ Giuseppina Scala

SOMMARIO: 1. Premessa - 2. La tutela del sentimento religioso in Canada: un inquadramento costituzionale - 3. Il reato di Hate Speech - 4. Il reato di blasfemia - 5. Considerazioni conclusive.

Legal features of the sacred in pluralist systems. Recent developments in the Canadian constitutional legal order

ABSTRACT: Nowadays the concept of "sacred" is characterised by a pluralization of the religious phenomena, which are barely defined from a legal point of view by the State. One of the criticalities of this scenario lies in the fact that there is no uniqueness on the limits that the State determines in outlining the boundaries of a religion. The risk of this lack of precise limits could be, inter alia, the offense to religious sentiment. The Author investigates the legal provisions that limit offences to religious sentiment such as the crime of hate speech and blasphemy in Canada. The latter is in fact a pluralist system considered as a good example for other States.

Download in PDF format

Trattamenti sanitari, diritto all’autodeterminazione ed etiche di fine vita dopo l’ordinanza n. 207 del 2018 della Corte costituzionale - ​ Angelo Licastro

SOMMARIO: 1. Considerazioni introduttive - 2. L’ordinanza n. 207 del 2018 della Consulta e la rilevanza costituzionale del “bene vita” - 3. L’„assolutezza” del diritto all’autodeterminazione terapeutica e la sua prevalenza sulla “indisponibilità” del diritto alla vita - 4. Il necessario riconoscimento del diritto all’aiuto al suicidio a tutela della visione personale della “dignità” nel morire ... - 5. ... e del divieto di discriminazioni nel darsi la morte attraverso il distacco delle macchine di sostegno vitale - 6. La “laicità” del biodiritto e il governo delle questioni “eticamente sensibili” - 7. L’apparente “neutralità” dell’opzione pro choice e la disciplina giuridica delle scelte di fine vita.

Health Treatments, Right to Self-determination and End-of-life Choices after Constitutional Court Ordinance No. 207/2018

ABSTRACT: The present essay deals with the issue regarding end-of-life choices after Italian Constitutional Court ruling No. 207/2018, which has prefigured, in certain exceptional situations, the partial unconstitutionality of the provision prohibiting aid to suicide (Article 580 of the Italian Criminal Code). The Author stresses that the patient’s right to refuse or interrupt life-saving treatment can be deemed to be protected by the Constitution, while the enactment of a right to assisted suicide into Italian law would require an ethical choice, which should instead be left to the discretionary assessment of the lawmakers.

Download in PDF format

Giusto processo e “amministrativizzazione” della procedura penale canonica - ​ Joaquín Llobell

Sommario: 1. Premessa - 2. L’accentramento ecclesiale della triplice potestà di governo - legislativa, amministrativa e giudiziale - nella persona del Vescovo diocesano e del Romano Pontefice - 3. La discrezionalità quale elemento tipico della potestà amministrativa - 4. I lavori del Pontificio Consiglio per i Testi Legislativi per la riforma del diritto sostantivo e procedurale amministrativo penale del “Codex Iuris Canonici” del 1983 - 5. L’equiparazione fra il “giusto processo” e il “processo giudiziale” è assoluta nella Chiesa? Sui “Principi” del 1967 per la riforma del “Codex Iuris Canonici” del 1917 e l’attuale annunciata riforma del diritto penale sostantivo e processuale - 6. Il diritto di difesa come mezzo per conoscere la verità e rendere giustizia: la conoscenza dell’accusa e delle prove contrarie, la possibilità di contrastarle con l’aiuto di un avvocato e l’obbligo di colui che decide di motivare il proprio provvedimento - 7. L’identità sostanziale fra colui che promuove l’azione penale e colui che decide la causa in prima istanza nella procedura penale canonica e il rispetto del diritto di difesa delle vittime, della comunità e dell’accusato. Sul Promotore di giustizia - 8. La conoscenza dei parametri del provvedimento giusto da parte di colui che deve decidere una causa e la necessità della certezza morale per la decisione di condanna in via amministrativa - 9. La frequente precaria stabilità dell’ufficio di giudice e la possibilità della delega “ad casum” come manifestazione dell’“amministrativizzazione” del sistema - 10. Il diritto al doppio grado di giurisdizione e la tutela della terzietà dell’organo predisposto per l’ultima istanza del ricorso amministrativo condizioni del giusto processo penale extragiudiziale (il Rescritto “ex audientia Sanctissimi” del 3 novembre 2014) - 11. Appendice. Cenni sull’iter di una causa sui “delicta graviora” riservati alla CDF. Verso un rafforzamento dell’indipendenza della “Feria IV” nei confronti del Congresso - 11.1. Sulla (innovativa) competenza assoluta della CDF per decidere i “delicta graviora” in “prima istanza” giudiziale e amministrativa - 11.2. Sul momento e sull’oggetto dell’obbligo dell’Autorità locale d’informare la CDF e sulle diverse possibili risposte del Dicastero - 11.3. I membri del Congresso della CDF - 11.4. I provvedimenti del Congresso sull’indagine previa dell’Autorità locale e la decisione dell’“Incaricato” del Congresso sul merito della causa - 11.5. L’iter nel processo giudiziale - 11.6. L’iter nella procedura extragiudiziale - 11.7. La competenza della “Feria IV” secondo la giurisprudenza della CDF precedente il Rescritto “ex audientia Sanctissimi”, 3 novembre 2014 - 11.8. Il nuovo Collegio, all’interno della CDF, per l’esame dei ricorsi di ecclesiastici per i “delicta graviora” creato con un Rescritto “ex audientia Sanctissimi”, 3 novembre 2014 - 11.9. Sulla competenza in via amministrativa del nuovo “Collegio” - 11.10. Sulla competenza in via giudiziale del nuovo “Collegio” - 12. Conclusioni.

The just process and the “administrativation” of the penal canonical procedure

ABSTRACT: The threefold power of governance proper to Diocesan Bishops and the Pope: legislative, judicial and administrative. Problems proposed and possible solutions. Common and distinctive elements of a just administrative and judicial procedure. Moral certitude as the prerequisite for every punitive decision. The right of access to a twofold level of jurisdiction in causes related to the common good. The impartiality of the deciding authority with respect to the parties and the authors of the challenged decisions. Equality between public and private parties. The right to know and to contradict the evidence. The “judicialization” of administrative power and the “administrativization” of judicial power. From the “matrimonialization” to the “penalization” of canonical procedure. The complexity of the equitable use of the supreme power of the Pope. From the right of a pontifical organ to call to itself a cause in first instance (judicial or aministrative) ad casum to the legislative centralization of such a competence in favor of the Roman Dicasteries, such that the Diocesan Bishop and his Tribunal are competent only when they receive such competence ad casum? The new deliberative College internal to the “Feria IV” of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith

Download in PDF format

Novità processuali in materia di nullità matrimoniale e giurisdizione canonica - ​ Marta Tigano Mariangela Galluccio

SSOMMARIO: 1. La riforma del processo matrimoniale nel solco del cammino sinodale della Chiesa … - 2. … e nel segno della Tradizione. Interpretazione sistematica della nuova normativa e principio dell’indissolubilità del matrimonio - 3. Le radici storiche del processus brevior: la “Episcopalis audientia” - 4. La “parabola” della “Episcopalis audientia”: contenuto e disciplina - 5. La “centralità” del Vescovo oggi come ieri - 6. La doppia sentenza conforme nell’ordinamento canonico … - 7 … e la sua evoluzione storico-giuridica: dalle origini fino al XX secolo - 8. La doppia sentenza conforme nelle Codificazioni del XX secolo - 9. La celerità dei giudizi e la pastorale della famiglia al centro della Riforma di Papa Francesco - 10. “Innovare nella tradizione: sfida e compito del canonista”.

Procedural novelties regarding marriage nullity and canonical jurisdiction

ABSTRACT: The purpose of the essay is to investigate the changes made to the discipline of the canonical process of marriage nullity by the Motu Proprio “Mitis Iudex Dominus Iesus”, in an attempt to verify whether the reform - which, as we know, has foreseen, among the other novelties, a shorter trial before the Bishop, and the elimination of the double sentence in conformity - both in line with the imprint proper to the canonical jurisdiction. In this perspective, the study will be dedicated to the historical reconstruction of the Processus brevior coram Episcopo and of the institute of the c.d. double sentence in conformity, at the end of which it seems possible to point out that the devolution to the Bishop of a shorter judgment - and the consequent reduction of the procedural forms - should not have undermined the cardinal principles of canonical jurisdiction.

Download in PDF format

Νόμοσ e συνεἱδησiς: dall’Antigone di Sofocle all’ordinamento canonico - ​ Beatrice Serra

SOMMARIO: 1. Perché Antigone: la tragedia di Sofocle come paradigma per ricostruire il rapporto tra legge e coscienza nel diritto canonico - 2. La dinamica degli opposti tra dimensione giuridica e dimensione politica. Perenne attualità di tale dinamica. In particolare: a) Il contrasto tra lex e ius. Il legame tra l’Antigone e le vicende della legge positiva come fonte del diritto -3. (segue) b) Il contrasto tra ragion di Stato e affetti privati - 4. Il lutto quale esito dell’antinomia tra legge e coscienza nell’Atene del V secolo. Ragioni di tale esito: a) assenza di efficaci elementi di ricomposizione del contrasto tra valori assoluti rappresentati da Antigone e Creonte. Assenza di ogni forma di mediazione del contrasto giuridico tra lex e ius - 5. (segue) b) L’intrinseca fragilità della scelta di Antigone: il richiamo al dato divino in funzione delle proprie istanze affettive. L’assenza di una concezione della coscienza quale autonoma dimensione interiore del singolo capace di fondare la violazione delle leggi della polis - 6. (segue) c) L’ineludibile esecuzione delle norme in contrasto. Antigone e Creonte privi di libertà di scelta davanti alla legge - 7. Dalle “assenze” nel rapporto tra legge e coscienza dell’Antigone alle “presenze” che connotano tale rapporto nell’assetto giuridico canonico. In particolare: a) La mediazione tra ius e lex come dimensione costitutiva della giuridicità ecclesiale - 8. (segue) b) La Sapienza divina quale oggettivo elemento di sintesi del contrasto tra legge e coscienza nella Chiesa - 9. (segue) c) La coscienza cristiana come struttura morale originaria che rispecchia la volontà divina dalla quale trae la forza di resistere alla norma - 10. (segue) d) La libertà umana quale presupposto irrinunciabile del rapporto tra legge e coscienza. Il giudizio della coscienza cristiana come testimone interiore che rende l’uomo responsabile dell’adempimento o inadempimento della norma.

Νόμοσ and συνεἱδησiς: from Sophocles' Antigone to the canonical order

ABSTRACT: The contribution reconstructs the essential lines of the relationship between law and conscience in Canon law starting from a re-reading of Sophocles's Antigone.

Download in PDF format

Riflessioni sul processo di nullità matrimoniale nel contesto della delibazione in Italia - ​ Graziano Mioli

SOMMARIO: 1. Premessa - 2. L'art. 60 del Decreto generale sul matrimonio canonico della CEI e l’obbligo di delibare - 3. La fase dell’indagine pregiudiziale e quella introduttiva - 4. La fase istruttoria e quella discussoria - 5. La fase decisoria - 5.1. Della redazione della sentenza - 5.2. Dell’interferenza delle questioni patrimoniali - 6. Conclusioni.

Reflections on marriage nullity proceedings in the context of the Italian exequatur procedure

ABSTRACT: The obligation to request the exequatur of the ecclesiastical sentence of marriage nullity, foreseen by the art. 60 of the General decree on the canonical matrimony of the CEI, constitutes in Italy a legal duty for the faithful who determines, for judges and lawyers, a corresponding moral duty (but which for lawyers can also become legal, under the professional mandate) of collaboration, during the various prejudicial and judicial phases of the canonical proceedings, in acquiring and making available all the useful elements in view of a exequatur procedure.

Download in PDF format

Organizzazioni di tendenza religiosa tra Direttiva europea, diritti nazionali e Corte di giustizia UE - ​ Pierangela Floris

SOMMARIO: 1. Premessa - 2. La Direttiva 2000/78 CE e i casi Egenberger e IR arrivati a Lussemburgo - 3. Autonomia delle chiese e tutela giurisdizionale dei diritti all’interno delle organizzazioni religiosamente orientate. I contenuti criptici delle pronunce di Lussemburgo - 4. Il requisito ideologico nelle organizzazioni di tendenza. Le integrazioni della Corte UE e le riletture in corso da parte confessionale - 5. L’art. 17 TFUE e l’attesa di chiarimenti.

Religious-Ethos Employers between European Directive, national laws and Court of Justice EU

ABSTRACT: This article examines two recent rulings of the Court of Justice of the European Union (cases Egenberger and IR). These are the first rulings on art. 4, par. 2, Directive 2000/78/EC on “occupational activities within churches and other public or private organisations the ethos of which is based on religion or belief“. On the one hand the author focuses on the passages concerning religious autonomy and jurisdictional protection of rights; on the other hand she highlights the links between the jurisprudence of the two European courts (CJEU and ECHR) and tries to reconcile the statements of the Court of Justice and those of the German constitutional Court on the limits to the autonomy of churches. However, the article highlights how the Court of Justice has not adequately addressed neither the art. 10 of the European Charter of Fundamental Rights EU, nor the art. 17 of the TFEU. As regards the ideological requirement set by art. 4, par. 2 of the European Directive, the study focuses on the additions made by the Court of Justice and recalls the reinterpretations of the ideological requirement recently adopted by the Catholic and Evangelical Churches in Germany.

Download in PDF format

Identità negate. Mutilazioni genitali femminili: la lotta dell’Europa contro una silenziosa violenza - ​ Tiziana Di Iorio

SOMMARIO: 1. Le pratiche di manipolazioni degli organi genitali femminili - 2. Procedura esercutiva e conseguenze degli atti di alterazione dei caratteri sessuali delle donne - 3. Radici socio-culturali delle pratiche di MGF - 4. Fattore religioso e atti modificativi dei genitali femminili - 5. Le strategie di prevenzione e di contrasto delle MGF nell’Unione europea - 6. Politiche legislative nella lotta contro le MGF - 7. Conclusioni.

Denied identities. Female genital mutilation: the fight of Europe against a silent violence

ABSTRACT: FGM refers to rituals of manipulation female genitalia and other procedures against female genital organs for non-medical reasons. Usually the practice is carried out on young girls, from childhood to teenagers. These rituals are carried out for cultural, religious and social reasons in the mistaken belief that they will produce a benefit to the girl (to safeguard her virginity, to prepare for marriage, etc.). No religious text prescribes the practice, but is rooted in the culture and beliefs of the communities that practice it. However some religious communities practice the FGM. Rituals do not help the health of the girl subjected, but they can lead to serious health complications or even to death of victim. So FGM is recognised a form of child abuse and a violation of women’s human rights. The EU is committed to eliminating FGM through strategic actions and legislative measures, but mainly changes in attitudes and beliefs among relevant communities are important to ensure FGM is abandoned. It is also important to fight FGM with direct involvement of the religious and political leaders of the communities where the rituals are diffuse. European States are called to cooperate with each other with strategic internal and external actions.

Download in PDF format

Brevi considerazioni a margine della proposta di legge n. 387 del 2018 “Disposizioni concernenti l’esposizione del Crocifisso nelle scuole e nelle pubbliche amministrazioni” - ​ Silvia Baldassarre

SOMMARIO: 1. Premessa − 2. Quadro normativo di riferimento ­− 3. Sulla valenza culturale del crocifisso − 4. Laicità, imparzialità, neutralità dei luoghi pubblici - 5. La rimozione dei crocifissi: una condotta da sanzionare? - 6. Osservazioni conclusive.

Draft law n. 387/18, “Provisions concerning the crucifix exhibition in schools and public administrations”: brief reflections.

ABSTRACT: The draft law n. 387 of March 26, 2018, (obligation to expose the Crucifix in schools and public administrations), is part of a complex legal-constitutional context of relations between state and religious phenomenon, characterized by multiple unresolved issues and problematic profiles. The law refers to the theory of cultural and identity value of the symbol, sustained with continuity by the administrative jurisprudence in disputes concerning the regulations governing the exposure of the crucifix. The questionability of this hermeneutical perspective, largely outdated, is clear and evident if we consider the most current judgments on the subject. The most critical issues of the current proposal will be examined.

Download in PDF format

Profili germinali della laicità. Un excursus storico - ​ Giovanni Blando

SOMMARIO: 1. Da Lutero alla Pace di Westfalia. Tra potestas indirecta e tolleranza - 1.1. Il cammino verso il modello laico illuminista. Hobbes, Locke e Spinoza - 2. I fondamenti illuministici della laicità - 2.1 Il contributo di Voltaire e Rousseau alla costruzione della laicità francese - 2.2. La libertà religiosa come nuova componente della laicità. Immanuel Kant - 3. I profili germinali della laicità - 3.1. Rapporto Stato/chiese - 3.2. Rapporto Stato/credenze religiose - 4. Conclusione.

Germinal Profiles of Secularism

ABSTRACT: The principle of secularism, as we usually think about it, is the outcome of sociological and historical events and the direct result of reflections of political morality. The present essay will provide a reflection about the “germinal profiles” of secularism. Starting with the breaking of Christian unity, arising from the Protestant reformation, the essay focuses on the strategy regarding the relations between State and Church, on the one hand, and between State and religious beliefs, on the other.

Download in PDF format

Appunti sulla circoncisione rituale nel diritto ecclesiastico e delle religioni - ​ Alex Borghi

SOMMARIO: 1. Premessa - 2. La giurisprudenza della Suprema Corte - 3. L’introduzione del § 1631, lett. d, nel BGB tedesco e la giurisprudenza di Colonia - 4. Risoluzioni e raccomandazioni del Consiglio d’Europa - 5. Il recente dibattito islandese - 6. Prospettive per l’Italia: necessità o ultroneità di una legge ad hoc? - 7. Osservazioni conclusive.

Notes on ritual circumcision in Ecclesiastical and Religious Law.

ABSTRACT: This paper deals with the delicate issue of ritual circumcision in Ecclesiastical and Religious Law. After having investigated the etymological origin of the word and reconstructed the history of the practice in question – distinguishing between circumcisions: a) therapeutic or prophylactic, b) ritual, c) cultural or ethnic – the focus is on the jurisprudential orientations of the Italian Court of Cassation. The solution proposed by the judgment of 24 November 2011, n. 43646, is carefully read and compared with the EU's law, the German legislation and the results of the recent Icelandic debate. Nevertheless, the absence of an ad hoc law on circumcision does not represent a vulnus in the Italian legal system, since the discipline can be found in the positive law in force, and even before in constitutional principles, as interpreted by the jurisprudence of merit and legitimacy. On the contrary, the essay raises the question that the introduction of a law on circumcision would not only be superfluous (for ethical and cultural reasons, even before legal ones), but also late".

Download in PDF format

Principio di legalità e ordinamento canonico e suoi riflessi nel diritto penale - ​ Giuseppe Sciacca

1 - Se taluni istituti giuridici, quali l’aequitas e l’epicheia, son peculiarissimi del diritto canonico sino a indurre qualche studioso a escluderne ogni derivazione concettuale e financo ogni tangenza - per quanto ai più manifesta e acclarata - con gli analoghi istituti rinvenibili in ambito civilistico, viceversa il principio di legalità, “suapte natura”, appare essenziale a ogni ordinamento giuridico civile proprio di uno stato democratico o, meglio, proprio di ogni tipo di stato di diritto, principalmente quello di origine democratica. (segue)

The Principle of Legality in the Canonical System and the Approach to Penal Law

In this article, the Author examines the principle of legality and its expression in the canonical system and in canonical penal law in particular. Opening with a reflection on the origins of the principle of legality in its ecclesiological context of the Church as a community of the faithful, the article then treats the principle of legality in its relation to the three powers of governance - administrative, legislative, judicial - and an essential aspect inherent to the exercise of each, namely discretionality, rationality, and moral certitude, in light of canonical penal law. The article closes with a brief mention of the principle of episcopal collegiality in light of the principle of legality.

Download in PDF format

Questioni di diritto patrimoniale canonico. Alcune riflessioni a partire dagli adempimenti conseguenti alla riforma italiana in materia di Terzo settore - ​ Pierluigi Consorti

SOMMARIO: 1. Premessa - 2. Lo stato dell’arte - 3. Enti ecclesiastici e Ets - 4. Enti ecclesiastici e libertà d’impresa - 5. Coerenza fra gli obblighi imposti dalla legge italiana e quelli previsti dal diritto canonico - 6. La scelta di adeguarsi alle norme italiane. I singoli adempimenti necessari. a) il regolamento - b) il patrimonio destinato - c) le scritture contabili.

Canon property law issues. Some thoughts around the obligations arising from the new Italian Third Sector law

ABSTRACT: The new Italian law in the field of the Third Sector provides for some burden on civilly recognized religious bodies, among which there are also Catholic ecclesiastical bodies. This paper deals with the canonical consequences of these obligations related to the general principles of Church law, as they are stated in the Code of Canon Law and the particular Italian canon law. The fulfillment of these government obligations is obviously not mandatory, however in many cases it may be timely, especially for institutions that already enjoy tax benefits that they could lose if they did not comply with the deadlines established by this new Italian law. Nevertheless, the central question is to verify whether certain obligations are lawful according to the Canon law. The essay raises the question of the provision of an “earmarked stock” and “internal rules” additional to their canonical Statutes, and especially the canonic assessment of commercial activities. If it is true that one has the right to do anything, but not everything is beneficial or constructive, catholic religious bodies should mind some questions before deciding to follow this law.

Download in PDF format

L’utile “fine del monopolio delle scienze ecclesiasticistiche”. Prime riflessioni su diritto ecclesiastico e autonomia differenziata delle Regioni ordinarie - ​ Giuseppe D'Angelo

SOMMARIO: 1. Premessa - 2. Autonomia differenziata delle Regioni ordinarie e disciplina pattizia dei rapporti tra lo Stato e le confessioni religiose diverse dalla cattolica: così diversi, così uguali - 3. L’utilità del raffronto. Risvolti procedurali e sul piano delle relazioni tra poteri dello Stato - 4. Questioni sostanziali. Unità vs. differenziazione ovvero autonomia vs. eguaglianza - 5. Il diritto ecclesiastico oltre il diritto ecclesiastico (per modo di dire).

About the useful “end of the monopoly of the ecclesiasticistic law sciences”. Focusing on the relationships between the ecclesiastical law (of the State) and the differentiation in the autonomy of the ordinary Regions

ABSTRACT: Many scholars identify a strong analogy between art. 116, c. 3 (dedicated to the differentiation in the autonomy of the ordinary statute Regions), and art. 8, c. 3 (dedicated to the relationships between the State and the religious denominations different from the Catholic one) of the Italian Constitution. The paper deals with this opinion to underline the importance of the ecclesiastical law (of the State) in order to analyze the doubtful impact of regional autonomy on the equal safeguard of constitutional rights and liberties (first of all, the religious freedom).

Download in PDF format

Historia salutis o privilegio curiale? Interrogativi sull’evoluzione del papato in monarchia costituzionale, sullo sfondo del collasso dei tentativi di codificazione del Novecento - ​ Francesco Zanchini

Sommario: 1. Nozioni introduttive - 1.1. Premessa - 1.2. Profili evolutivi del potere costituente nella Chiesa - 1.3. Verso una nuova costituzione materiale? - 2. Un sistema costituzionale non codificato - 2.1. Caratteristiche generali - 2.2. La “materia” costituzionale - 2.3. Debolezza politica (non tecnica) della dottrina canonistica - 3. Sullo stato della separazione dei poteri - 3.1. Il decreto di scioglimento del matrimonio non consumato - 3.2. La “sentenza” di nullità di matrimonio “ex certo et authentico documento” - 3.3. Discrezionalità pastorale e giustizia penale - 4. Fonti normative - 5. Profili giurisprudenziali - 6. Bibliografia essenziale.

Download in PDF format

Considerazioni sul genocidio: ipotesi di comparazione e conseguenze nella tutela del diritto di libertà religiosa - ​ Domenico Bilotti

SOMMARIO: 1. Una premessa: le origini del dibattito sul genocidio e la difficile genesi della sua giuridificazione - 2. Processi ermeneutici e tentativi espansivi in merito alla nozione di genocidio: rischi e problematiche. Il ruolo dei profili religiosi - 3. Qualificazioni tipologico-effettuali del genocidio. Percorsi e prospettive - 4. Appunti per una casistica giurisdizionale internazionale del genocidio: riscontri formali e casi controversi - 5. Disagevoli profili conclusivi: l’attualità del genocidio e delle sue conseguenze istituzionali nel cuore dell’Europa.

Observations about the genocide: hypotheses of comparison and consequences on the legal protection of religious freedom

ABSTRACT: Talking about the genocide implies to recall a wide doctrinal processing, including refined strategies to put into effects the legal definition of genocide itself. This conceptual effort should combine the historical reconstruction with a dramatic but intransigent analysis of the most recent massacres. The constant presence of religious conflicts in concrete representations of genocide undoubtedly shows how the stance for religious freedom shall be definitely urgent and participated, because genocides are a maybe surprising but anyway unquestionable part of our most recent legal history and systems, including the institutional development of the European Union.

Download in PDF format

Evaluation of the exhibit “Amen” of Abel Azcona - ​ Igor V. Ponkin Viktor I. Slobodchikov

SUMMARY: 1. Introduction. Object of the evaluation: description of the exhibit – 2. Main part. An evaluation - 2.1. Communicative technique of combining the sacred with the low and vulgar associated with homosexual acts and the corresponding semantics condemned in the traditional Catholic religion - 2.2. Communicative technique of metonymic replacement (substitution) of one sign with another - 3. Conclusions.

Download in PDF format

Specificità del Diritto amministrativo canonico e “amministrazione di missione”. La ministerialità ecclesiale come fattore riqualificativo per una autonomia ontologico-disciplinare - ​ Francesco Rea

SOMMARIO: 1. Ministerialità e missionarietà del Diritto canonico - 2. La norma missionis come statuto costituzionale del Diritto canonico - 3. La communio come genus della corresponsabilità ecclesiale - 4. Trapianto da donatore non compatibile e problematiche di rigetto: non equiparabilità tra Diritto amministrativo canonico e statale - 5. Il concetto sui generis di Diritto amministrativo nella Chiesa cattolica - 6. Diversità strutturali nell’organigramma ecclesiale - 7. Il paradigma europeo come “analogatum princeps” del sistema canonico: verso un’amministrazione “di missione”.

Specificity of canonical administrative law and “mission administration”. Ecclesial ministry as a requalification marker for  ontological-disciplinary autonomy

ABSTRACT: The need to configure a correct boundary within which to draw up the structure of administrative activity in the Church responds to the urgency to avoid undue and inaccurate transposition of concepts proper to secular juridical fields in the background of Canon law. In fact, in the Church it is not possible to speak of a "public administration-entity" but of an "administration-activity". It is not so much the subject that has to be examined, in view of a claim that is not suited to the foundational (top-down) and non-consociative (bottom-up) nature of the Church; as much as the concrete activities to be carried out within it, in the ideal of a shared responsibility that does not deprive the individual faithful of juridical positions that they can claim, but directs them within correct coordinates. The faithful do not live a dimension of "homo homini lupus", to reach an individual salvific finish line where one place to be conquered excludes that one of another. On the contrary, they pursue, united under the one baptism, the implementation of the mission of Christ, also through those juridical instruments which the Church has endowed through the story, but which are to be understood in their precise peculiarities, even though a relationship can not be excluded of mutual growth with secular law. According to this paradigm, the example of European Union law can be a valid benchmark for describing the particularities of ecclesial reality in a sector as specific as that of administrative law.

Download in PDF format

Confessioni e comunità religiose nell’Europa dell’Est, pluralismo religioso e politiche legislative degli Stati - ​ Giovanni Cimbalo

SOMMARIO: Sistemi di classificazione dei rapporti e individuazione degli interlocutori istituzionali delle confessioni religiose - 2. Il “laboratorio” dell’Europa dell’Est come luogo di sperimentazione del pluralismo intra confessionale - 3. La gestione delle relazioni tra Stato e confessioni religiose attraverso gli uffici - 4. I problemi nuovi posti dal moltiplicarsi delle confessioni nei diversi paesi europei - 4.1. L’area baltica - 4.2. (segue) Le Repubbliche russofone - 4.3. (segue) Le Repubbliche dell’Europa Centrale - 4.4. (segue) I Balcani Orientali - 4.5. (segue) I territori della ex Repubblica Jugoslava - 4.6. (segue) Le scelte differenziate delle Repubbliche ex jugoslave in materia di Rapporti tra Stato e confessioni religiose - 5. La felice anomalia albanese - 6. Un contributo all’elaborazione di linee guida ai rapporti tra Stato e confessioni religiose in Europa.

Confessions and religious communities in Eastern Europe, religious pluralism and legislative policies of the States

ABSTRACT: The intervention reconstructs the supporting lines of the activity of the national office of each legal system in charge with the maintenance of the relations between the State and the confessions and religious communities in the Eastern European countries. Through this perspective, the ecclesiastical politics of 19 countries is reconstructed, highlighting the genesis and the peculiar characteristics of their legislations and highlighting the underlying lines that are at the root of the choices of their systems. Particular attention is dedicated to the definition of the different models to which the States refer in relation to their effectiveness in maintaining religious peace while respecting the principle of equality and freedom among the various religious confessions. The article aims to be a contribution to the development of guidelines for relations between the state and religious confessions in Europe.
 

Download in PDF format

Radicalizzati jihadisti: profilazione e deradicalizzazione Constitution-compliant - ​ Laura Sabrina Martucci

SOMMARIO: 1. Gli scenari preventivi: il terrorismo a chiamata individuale - 2. Le prevent strategies. I livelli di intervento - 3. L’islamista, ovvero il type consumer del messaggio radicalizzante - 4. La pericolosità sociale indicatore laico-giudiziario di radicalizzazione - 5. Schedatura, provvedimenti di deradicalizzazione e laicità della “reazione” dello Stato - 6. I radicalizzati: indexing risk factors Constitution-compliant.

Download in PDF format

Verso un nuovo dialogo filosofico tra profano e religioso - ​ Patrick Nerhot

SOMMARIO: 1. Il “suono”: fenomeno comuno al metodo religioso e profano - 2. Tempo e trascendenza - 3. Sapere e non saputo, medesimo e indicibile - 4. Presenza assenza - 5. Il prima dopo.

Towards a new philosophical dialogue between profane and religious

ABSTRACT: Christian religious philosophy builts itself from a very precise idea of the mortality whose time cannot as such manifest the truth of human being. Profane philosophy, we are in the eighteenth century, Enlightenment, asserts itself as the antithesis of such construction. Truth of human being belongs exclusively to his mortality, that is to say a determination of time. Everything becomes “history”, in other words, truth of a temporality of which the Reason is reappropriated. Here is the primary sense of the Reason of Enlightenment. This article is a critical interrogation about this pure methodological question.

Download in PDF format

Le istituzioni educative nella Costituzione italiana - ​ Pasquale Lillo

SOMMARIO: 1. Ricognizione costituzionale del fenomeno educativo - 2. L’educazione familiare - 3. L’educazione scolastica - 4. L’educazione religiosa.

Educational Institutions in the Italian Constitution

ABSTRACT: According to the current Constitution, Italy presents itself as a pluralist and participatory democracy, in which certain functions aimed at enhancing the human person are not taken directly by the State – except in exceptional cases in which the public authorities intervene, for reasons of necessity, in a subsidiary or supplementary way – but they are normally assigned to specific social subjects (or formations), among which the educational institutions have a special and qualified position. The present contribution intends to highlight that the Italian “social State” does not present itself as a “educating State” in its own educational models that the public structures impose in an authoritarian way on the single components of the national collectivity. On the other hand, the Italian Constitution, in recognizing social relevance to the educational function, assigns its concrete management to certain “"pedagogical agencies” or “educational institutions” operating autonomously within the civil society: among which the qualified family holds a qualified position. School and religious confessions. They do not operate in the name or on behalf of the State, but operate within a framework of legal, cultural and institutional guarantees and pluralism, within a normative framework dictated in this regard by the constitutional text and by ordinary legislation. By carrying out the special role assigned to them by the Italian legal system, educational institutions participate in the democratic dynamics of the country, contributing with their work to the construction and evolution of the civil and national community.

Download in PDF format

Diritto, religione e letteratura. Alcune suggestioni su Chiesa e ministero petrino a partire da The Young Pope di Paolo Sorrentino - ​ Luigi Mariano Guzzo

SOMMARIO: 1. Una premessa epistemologica: “Diritto e letteratura” vs. “Diritto, religione e letteratura” - 2. The Young Pope, ovvero l’ordinamento ecclesiale tra dimensione narrativa e dimensione normativa - 3. La Chiesa come teatro: il vescovo di Stendhal e il Papa di Sorrentino - 4. Chiesa e potere, tra concezione giuspositivistica ed etica utilitaristica - 5. Prime conclusioni: la tensione tra ortodossia e ortoprassi nell’istituzione ecclesiale.

Law, Religion and Literature. Some notes on Ecclesial legal order and Petrine ministry from The Young Pope by Paolo Sorrentino

ABSTRACT: This paper is divided in two main parts. In the first part, I propose an epistemological analysis on the features of the field of “Law and Literature”, in which we can construct the specific category of “Law, Religion and Literature”. In the second part, I do a “Law, Religion and Literature” analysis about Ecclesial legal order and Petrine ministry starting from The Young Pope, the movie created and directed by Paolo Sorrentino.

Download in PDF format

L’autocefalia della chiesa ortodossa ucraina, interpretazioni dottrinali e strutture ecclesiali a confronto - ​ Vittorio Parlato

SOMMARIO: 1. Chiese autocefale e chiese autonome - 2. La situazione ecclesiastica ucraina - 3. La concessione dell’autonomia nel 1990 alla chiesa ortodossa ucraina - 4. La normativa delle chiese ortodosse circa il conferimento dell’autocefalia - 5. Il ruolo del patriarca ecumenico circa la cura pastorale di quanti fedeli ortodossi vivono nei territori della diaspora - 6. Il ruolo del patriarca ecumenico circa il conferimento dell’autocefalia alla chiesa ucraina - 7. Le obiezioni in linea di diritto e in linea di fatto da parte della chiesa russa - 8. Il tomos dell’autocefalia, prerogative e limiti - 9. Le conseguenze canoniche - 10. La nuova chiesa ucraina autocefala e le altre chiese ortodosse.

The autocephaly of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church, doctrinal interpretations and ecclesial structures in comparison

ABSTRACT: The granting of the autocephaly to the Ukrainian Orthodox Church has provoked much controversy both with regard to the authority authorized to grant, both regarding the requesting church, and with regard to the involvement of other Orthodox churches with jurisdiction in that territory. In the absence of specific legislation, I took into account the modalities related to the previous concessions and to the subsequent recognition by the other autocephalous churches. The claimed jurisdiction of Constantinople on Ukrainian territory and the objections in law and in fact by the Russian church have been highlighted. From last an indication to the content of the tomos of “autocefalia” and the rights that the ecumenical patriarch is reserved.

Download in PDF format

La religione atea di Dworkin e la divinizzazione del valore - ​ Andrea Porciello

SOMMARIO: 1. Ateismo religioso e valori - 2. Ateismo moderato, neo-ateismo e ateismo religioso - 3. Alcune considerazioni su indipendenza e inevitabilità dei valori - 4. Conclusioni.

Dworkin’s Atheistic Religion and the Divinization of Value

ABSTRACT: This essay critically discusses some of the central ideas of Ronald Dworkin’s last book, Religion Without God. In particular, it will be argued that the idea of “religion without God” is not a form of atheism, as Dworkin claims, but a pure religious attitude in which the idea of “theistic entity” of traditional religion is replaced by a new and not less problematic entity, the idea of “value”.

Download in PDF format

L’Europa di chi non crede - ​ Nicola Colaianni

Son passati quasi trent’anni dacché tra le varie dichiarazioni apposte in calce al trattato di Maastricht comparve abbastanza inaspettatamente quella che impegna l’Unione Europea al “dialogo trasparente, costante e regolare” con “le chiese e le associazioni o comunità religiose” non più e non meno, tuttavia, che con le “organizzazioni filosofiche e non confessionali”. Dichiarazione apparentemente innocua, giacché espressamente si esclude che da essa possa essere pregiudicato lo status a quelle organizzazioni assegnato dai diritti nazionali, ma politicamente impegnativa per l’Unione, tanto che fece strada e si riversò nell’art. 17 del TFUE, assumendo così un carattere anche giuridicamente impegnativo. (segue)

Non-believer’s Europe

ABSTRACT: In spite of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, which puts on the same footing the status of the churches and of the humanist organizations, the status  of believers and non-believers is not the same in each state, regardless its model (the paper quotes briefly the features of United Kingdom, France, Belgium, Italy, Germany  and Malta). The reason lies in a kind of mass religious tradition, which at present is even more hard to defeat because of the rampant populism, which takes advantage also of the religion. The antidote stays in the pluralistic – not monist and excluding the differences -  secularism in order to grant the same dignity of believers also to both differently believers and non-believers.

Download in PDF format

A 170 anni dalla costituzione della repubblica romana del 3 luglio 1849 - ​ Sergio Lariccia

SOMMARIO: 1. - Premessa - 2. Costituzione della repubblica romana e costituzione della repubblica italiana: interesse di una comparazione - 3. L’assemblea costituente - 4. I principi fondamentali - 5.  Diritti e doveri dei cittadini - 6.  L’organizzazione della repubblica romana - 7. Natura e peculiarità della carta costituzionale della repubblica romana. In particolare, la procedura di revisione e la rigidezza della costituzione -  8. Conclusioni.

Download in PDF format

A Comparative Survey on Islamic Riba and Western Usury - ​ Andrea Borroni

SOMMARIO 1. Introduction - 2. Premise - 3. Ancient history - 4. Roman law - 5. Aquinas and Canon law - 6. 16th Century: Protestantism and the mercantile era - 7. 17th century: Jusnaturalism - 8. 18th century and 19th centuries: industrialization and capitalism - 9. The prohibition of riba - 10. Similarities between the sharia prescriptions and the ancient Jewish ones - 11. Riba and its recent openings - 12. Riba prohibition in the twentieth century and the sharia-compliant financial instruments - 13. Solutions - 14. Islamic Finance - 15. Conclusions.

ABSTRACT: The article addresses the theme of usury taking into account various viewpoints and traditions, pausing in particular on the Western and Islamic notions of lending at interest, in order to outline its distinctive features in the present days as well as throughout its historical evolution. The author applies a comparative research method, examining both the differences and similarities between the Western and Muslim concept of usury so to present an accurate picture of the phenomenon. In fact, the article aims at answering the latest questions concerning the possibility for the Muslim model to be a valuable resource in overcoming the keep going financial crisis.

Download in PDF format

La laicità come esigenza della ragione: rileggendo Dietrich Bonhoeffer - ​ Paola Chiarella

SOMMARIO: 1. Laicità necessaria - 2. Il Cristianesimo: una fede scandalosa - 3. La maggiore età del mondo - 4. Ritrovare Dio da adulti - 5. Provvisorietà dell’etica cristiana - 6. Führer e Verführer: lo scambio delle vesti e la fragilità del male.

Secularism as requirement of reason: the actuality of Dietrich Bonhoeffer

ABSTRACT: Dietrich Bonhoeffer is a very significant figure of the Protestant theology. Having experienced the most dramatic period of the German history he is well remembered as “resistant” to the National Socialism, but he deserves also to be reconsidered because of his defense, as believer, of the value of “secularism”, necessary to safeguard an authentic profession of faith.

Download in PDF format

Fra Dante e Lutero. Centralità culturale della riflessione di Emilio Betti sull’interpretazione teologica nella tradizione occidentale - ​ Francesco Zanchini

SOMMARIO: 1. Preambolo - 2. Il “mundus hic”, sul quale all’ermeneutica in funzione normativa era dato riflettere la vigilia della metà del secolo XX – 3. (segue) Parallelismi nell’itinerario della ricerca di Emilio Betti e di Giuseppe Capograssi - 4. Lettura inclusiva implicita del mondo globale nelle contraddizioni del “secolo breve” e del suo ethos egemone - 5. (segue) Raccordi comparatistici principali nella memoria storica di Emilio Betti: l’età di Costantino, di Bartolo, di Leibniz. E i dubbi elusi (Napoleone, Pio IX, Bismarck), o di necessità postigli dalla storia spirituale germanica (la Riforma, con la sua apparente discontinuità fatale dalla tradizione gregoriano-cattolica) – 6. L’impatto su Betti dell’eccezionale acume critico-filologica dell’esegesi biblica protestante. Uno scontro inedito tra scienze storiche e credenze assorbite dal popolo cattolico sia per violenza istituzionale subita, sia mediante l’ermeneutica unificatrice della “Vulgata”, inficiata dai troppi limiti della versione di Girolamo. La Bibbia in tedesco di Lutero: tra filologia umanista e prudenza pastorale - 7. (segue) Ragione e torto nel dibattito sulla giustificazione. Concordanza delle due dottrine nella convinzione dell’inanità degli sforzi del credente di vivere una vita eticamente razionale nei rapporti con Dio e col prossimo. Dai dubbi su una disconferma cattolica della Riforma al graduale riconoscimento di un’incompiutezza del sistema valoriale “cattolico” - 8. Emersione di un ethos borghese aconfessionale dagli orientamenti prevalenti nella coscienza cristiana come fattore immanente alla storia della laicità. Il buon costume come categoria civilistica; riconoscimento di un suo possibile percorso extracostituzionale, parallelo a quello delle norme imperative e dell’ordine pubblico – 9. Permanenza-impermanenza dell’accettazione di un tale possibilismo policentrico nella generalità delle formazioni confessionali: “via crucis” dell’idea di una tolleranza nella convivenza di più mondi extraeuropei, costretti in una nuova (e più complessa) fase di globalizzazione. Rinvio.

Download in PDF format

Dignitas connubii and marriages of Non-Catholics. An achievement to be maintained, improved and complemented - ​ Burkhard J. Berkmann

SOMMARIO: 1. Introduzione - 2. Norme di conflitto del diritto canonico - 3. Visione d’insieme delle disposizioni - 3.1. Competenza dei tribunali ecclesiastici - 3.2. Il diritto processuale applicabile - 3.3. Il diritto sostanziale applicabile - 3.4. Il valore del diritto divino - 4. Dignitas connubii e Mitis iudex - 4.1. La Dignitas connubii è ancora in vigore? - 4.2. Processus brevior per matrimoni di non cattolici? - 5. L'art. 4 DC nella prassi giudiziale - 5.1. Una sentenza a Vancouver - 5.2. Aspetti processuali - 5.3. Il diritto sostanziale da applicare - 5.4. Terminologia - 6. Argomenti non presenti nella Dignitas connubii - 6.1. Riconoscimento di sentenze di nullità matrimoniale straniere - 6.2. Vizio di forma accertabile nell'esame degli sposi - 6.3. Quale tribunale cattolico è competente? - 7. Uno sguardo a possibili sviluppi futuri.

Dignitas connubii and marriages of Non-Catholics. An achievement to be maintained, improved and complemented

Abstract: The instruction Dignitas connubii of 2005, Art 2-4, deals with marriages, in which one or both parts are non-Catholic - whether baptized or not. This is a great progress initiated by the Second Vatican Council, even if there still are some omissions and ambiguities in the regulations. Since 2005, some jurisprudential experience could be gained and further official documents concerning non-Catholic marriages have been issued. They are mainly dealing with Orthodox Christians and are dedicated to the recognition of matrimonial sentences, the determination of formal defects and competence issues. Mitis iudex does not mention anything concerning this topic but in case a new instruction should be made now, the named Articles would have to be maintained, improved and complemented.

Download in PDF format

Libertà religiosa collettiva e principio di non discriminazione nel sistema ‘costituzionale’ dell’Unione europea - ​ Maria Elena Gennusa

SOMMARIO: 1. Autonomia delle organizzazioni religiose e diritti dei singoli: il problema ‘classico’ del contemperamento - 2. Il problema del contemperamento dinanzi alla Corte di giustizia. I casi Vera Egenberger e JQ: stessa narrativa per due gemelli (in parte) diversi? - 3. Il profilo sostanziale delle decisioni: le dimensioni della libertà religiosa e il principio di non discriminazione - 4. Il profilo ordinamentale: Carta dei diritti e principi generali del diritto dell’Unione europea nel rapporto fra sistemi.

Collective religious freedom and principle of non-discrimination in the ‘constitutional’ system of the European Union

ABSTRACT: In the two recently handed down Judgments in the cases Vera Egenberger and JQ, the Court of Justice of the European Union for the first time interpreted Article 4, par. 2 of the Anti-discrimination Framework Directive (Directive 2000/78/EC) admitting a ‘religious exemption’ in favour of Churches and other religious organisation, and ruled on the horizontal application of the right not to be discriminated against in situations coming within the scope of EU law. The paper explores the substantive implications of those Judgments for the collective religious freedom and their contribution in clarifying the horizontal direct effect of the fundamental rights and principles enshrined in the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union.

Download in PDF format

Opinion on act (decision), adopted by the Holy Synod of the Patriarchate of Constantinople on 11 October 2018 - ​ Igor V. Ponkin

SUMMARY: 1. Introduction - 2. Main Part. An Examination - 3. Complete exhaustion of the subject of the executive act adopted by the Patriarchate of Constantinople in 1686 - 4. Assessment of the actions from the perspective of the legislation of the Republic of Turkey - 5. Conclusions.

Download in PDF format

Tra istanze di riforma e fughe in avanti giurisprudenziali: il Consiglio di Stato e l’„esonero” dall’ora di religione in corso d’anno - ​ Paolo Cavana

SOMMARIO: - 1. L’insegnamento religioso nella scuola pubblica nel dibattito attuale: limiti e criticità - 2. Tendenze in Europa e proposte di riforma in Italia - 3. Una discutibile sentenza del Consiglio di Stato sul diritto di scelta dell’Irc - 4. Analisi della fattispecie e ricostruzione del quadro normativo - 5. Dalla richiesta di esonero (Concordato del 1929) al diritto di scelta dell’Irc (Accordo del 1984): il principio di non discriminazione - 6. La scelta dell’Irc come un diritto assoluto privo di limiti (temporali): rilievi critici - 7. Scelta dei non avvalentisi e natura curricolare dell’Irc - 8. Conseguenze sul piano pratico: effetti pregiudizievoli per gli alunni - 9. Un sistema a sliding doors per l’Irc? - 10. Osservazioni conclusive.

Debating Religious Education in Italian State Schools: the Council of State and the right to choose at any time during the school year

ABSTRACT: The paper starts with some preliminary remarks on the legal framework that regulates religious education in Italian State schools. It then analyzes and comments upon a recent decision taken by the higher administrative court (Council of State) that upheld a previous judgment of a lower court stating the right for the parents of a student to choose whether to take - or to withdraw from - religious education at any time during the school year, and not only at the beginning as provided by law.

Download in PDF format

Le regole alimentari religiose e i menù delle mense scolastiche: una sfida per la laicità? - ​ Corrado Del Bò

SOMMARIO: 1. Introduzione - 2. La libertà religiosa e le regole alimentari religiose - 3. Le regole alimentari religiose e la laicità dello Stato - 4. Il menù quaresimale - 5. L’immunità dall’esposizione - 6. Conclusioni.

Religious dietary rules and school lunch menus: a challenge for secularism?

ABSTRACT: The paper starts from a case of dietary pluralism to discuss the possibility to justify menus sensitive to different religious dietary rules in schools’ canteens. Building on an analysis of the idea of secularism, both in its legal interpretation and in its philosophical understanding in terms of neutrality, I try to show that providing for menus sensitive to different religious dietary rules does not amount to a breach of secularism; it is, rather, a legitimate consequence of the protection of individuals’ rights to freedom of conscience and religion. Moreover, whenever institutions take action to devise and implement such menus they can be taken to act on a commitment to respecting the beliefs of minority groups in society without expecting that these groups, which are often migrant communities suffering of well-known problems of social integration, take on the burden to put forward public claims.

Download in PDF format

“A chiare lettere - Confronti” • 30 anni di bene comune - ​ Giorgio Feliciani

SOMMARIO: 1. Premessa - 2. Dagli assegni di congrua all’8 per mille - 3. L’8 per mille per il bene comune della Chiesa - 4. L’8 per mille per il bene comune della società. Per una piena attuazione della libertà religiosa - 5. L’opera dei sacerdoti per il bene comune della società - 6. L’8 per mille per le emergenze del Paese - 7. L’otto per mille per il patrimonio storico e artistico della Nazione - 8. Per un’efficace opera di promozione.

Download in PDF format

Pluralismo religioso e integrazione europea: le nuove sfide - ​ AA. VV. (Angelucci e altri) Antonio Angelucci Maria Ilia Bianco Wojciech Brozowski Marco Croce Lucia Giannuzzo Sina Haydn-Quindeau Corinne Maioni Francesca Mauri Joshua Moir Stefano Montesano Costanza Nardocci Alessandro Negri Marcello Toscano Alessia Tranfo Julia Wagner Giovanni Zaccaroni Marco Parisi Filippo Croci Rosa Geraci

Il 28 settembre 2018, presso l’Università degli Studi di Milano-Bicocca, si è tenuto un convegno internazionale co-finanziato dall’Unione Europea, che ha visto la partecipazione di giovani studiosi delle più diverse discipline giuridiche, italiani e stranieri. I relatori, selezionati in seguito ad una “call for papers”, cui è stata data ampia pubblicità in Italia e all’estero, si sono confrontati sul tema del pluralismo religioso nel sistema europeo e, soprattutto, nella recente giurisprudenza delle Corti sovranazionali. (continua)

Download in PDF format

La rilevanza ecclesiasticistica della riforma del Terzo settore. Il cinque per mille - ​ Giuseppe D'Angelo

SOMMARIO: 1. Premessa - 2. La revisione del cinque per mille tra sollecitazioni della magistratura contabile e riforma del Terzo settore - 3. L’ancoraggio costituzionale del cinque per mille: sussidiarietà orizzontale e democrazia fiscale - 4. La natura giuridica dell’istituto e la perimetrazione della volontà di destinazione espressa dal contribuente - 5. La configurazione originaria del meccanismo nelle valutazioni critiche della Corte dei conti e i conseguenti interventi correttivi - 6. La ricollocazione nell’alveo della riforma del Terzo settore. Le novità del d.lgs. n. 111 del 2017 - 7. Profili problematici di interesse ecclesiasticistico: a) gli enti religiosi come possibili beneficiari … - 8. (segue) b) gli oneri di conformazione (bilanciata) alle prescrizioni in tema di trasparenza, pubblicità e efficacia della gestione dei flussi finanziari derivanti dal cinque per mille … - 9 (segue) c) l’otto per mille - 10. Tra sintesi e prospettiva. Questioni pratico-applicative e significato ricostruttivo-sistematico nella valutazione delle ricadute ecclesiasticistiche del cinque per mille.

The effects of the legal reform of the Third sector on the Ecclesiastical law (of the State). The case of “cinque per mille”.

ABSTRACT: The article deals with the effects of the Italian Reform of the Third Sector on the Ecclesiastical law of the State and focuses on the peculiar measure of financial aid called “cinque per mille”, as governed by the legislative decree n. 111/2017. The author analyzes some problematic issues involved by this decree and underlines its importance in achieving the goal of a more amply and extended awareness of the today meaning of religious freedom as s well as of the relationships between the State and the Church.

Download in PDF format

L’elezione di un prete cattolico a Rettore dell’Università di Strasburgo: “une tempête dans un verre d’eau”? - ​ Angelo Licastro

SOMMARIO: 1. La vicenda - 2. Gli argomenti pro e contro l’elezione di un sacerdote a Rettore di una università pubblica - 3. Le incompatibilità dei ministri di culto - 4. La possibile incidenza dei principi riguardanti la c.d. “laïcité d’apparence” - 5. L’intervento dei giudici amministrativi - 6. Conclusioni: l’irrilevanza dell’ordinazione non accompagnata dall’esercizio di funzioni ministeriali.

The election of a Catholic priest as Rector of the University of Strasbourg: “Much ado about nothing”?

ABSTRACT: This study examines the question of compatibility between the principle of neutrality of public services in force in French law and the election of a minister of the Catholic religion as Rector of a public university. The Author rules out the existence of any form of incapacity. However, since the duty of discretion of the public official (“devoir de réserve”) operates even outside the exercise of his functions, it may limit the freedom to exercise pastoral ministry in specific cases, as well as the performance of the most typical tasks that are inherent in the status of minister of worship, due to the inevitable repercussions on the image of the university.

Download in PDF format

Neutralidad, diversidad y celebración de las festividades religiosas en la escuela pública - ​ Silvia Meseguer Velasco

SUMARIO: 1. Introducción - 2. Libertad religiosa y celebración de las festividades religiosas - 3. La neutralidad ideológico-religiosa de los centros educativos públicos - 4. Celebración de festividades religiosas en la escuela de titularidad pública - 4.1. Celebración de festividades que presentan un significado religioso y una tradición cultural - 4.2. La respuesta de los Tribunales de Justicia en materia de celebraciones religiosas - 4.3. Algunas claves para la solución de estos conflictos - 5. Celebración de las festividades religiosas en el horario escolar - 5.1. Marco jurídico de las festividades en el ámbito escolar - 5.2.  Discriminación de los grupos religiosos minoritarios - 6. Consideraciones finales: la acomodación razonable de las creencias religiosas.

Neutrality, diversity and celebration of religious festivities in public schools

Abstract: This paper analyzes some legal conflicts derived from the celebration of religious festivities in ​​the public school. On the one hand, the celebration of certain festivals that, while showing a cultural tradition, at the same time, present a religious meaning, mainly of Christian inspiration. On the other, when permission is requested to celebrate and commemorate such festivities during school hours. Beyond the concrete problem, it is important to start from the position of inclusive neutrality that public authorities must adopt to manage the religious diversity that manifests itself in this specific area and which, in turn, is the best way to guarantee the right of parents to choose the education they wish for their children.

Download in PDF format

Le origini del fondamentalismo cristiano: profili comparatistici e prospettive di ricerca - ​ Domenico Bilotti

SOMMARIO: 1. Considerazioni introduttive sul fondamentalismo odierno: alcune differenze rispetto ai movimenti omologhi dei decenni precedenti - 2. L’influenza del fondamentalismo sulla demografia religiosa e sul contenzioso giurisdizionale negli Stati Uniti d’America - 3. Il fondamentalismo americano protestante e le omologhe istanze etiche e giuridiche di gruppi religiosi contemporanei - 4. La Chiesa di Gesù Cristo dei Santi degli Ultimi Giorni: le origini di una protesta contro la teologia ottocentesca - 5. L’escatologia teocratica dei Testimoni di Geova e le conseguenze ordinamentali - 6. Possibili conclusioni: il ruolo del fondamentalismo cristiano nella conformazione attuale delle istituzioni statunitensi.

The origins of the Christian fundamentalism: comparative approaches and research perspectives

ABSTRACT: The aim of this essay is to demonstrate the Christian roots of the public discourse concerning fundamentalism, its disciplines, groups and legal consequences. This issue implies to go back to the first Christian fundamentalist experiences born and raised during last two centuries in America (with a peculiar focus on the United States). By reconsidering a wide historical period and a not simple variety of local religious communities, it will be possible to underline a substantial and concurrent beginning for similar movements in the progressive development of Jehovah’s Witnesses, new wave Lutheran and Baptist Churches, Church of Latter Day Saints: some of the same faiths and cults still effecting the American recent ecclesiastical controversies.

Download in PDF format

Pietro I di Russia e la tentazione del Protestantesimo - ​ Giovanni Codevilla

SOMMARIO: 1. L’infanzia di Pietro - 2. Il rione degli stranieri - 3. La Grande Ambasciata - 4. L’inizio delle riforme - 5. Pietro e il monachesimo - 6. Il manifesto sulla tolleranza religiosa - 7. Pietro e la religione - 8. La subordinazione della Chiesa - 9. Feofan Prokopovyč e il suo ruolo determinante - 10. L’abolizione del Patriarcato - 11. Il Santo Sinodo governante e la paralisi della Chiesa.

The Protestant Influence on the Church Reform of Peter the Great

ABSTRACT: Peter the Great first comes into contact with the outside world through long familiarity with the German Quarter, a fluctuating Muscovite community of foreigners with its Lutheran and Calvinist churches, and with subsequent and extensive travel in the Protestant Lands (1697-1698), where he has ample time to appraise the role of sovereign as head of the church. The relationship of the tsar to his church is paradoxical; on the one hand, it emanates laws contrary to the principles sanctioned by the Church's Councils and organizes blasphemous parodies with The All-Joking, All-Drunken Synod of Fools and Jesters; conversely, he imposes rigidly traditional religious behaviors on the military. Rejecting his role and duty as Servant of the Salvation of Souls, he assumes a secular stance: Protector of the wellbeing of the community, (Vsenarodnaja pol’za). This swerve subordinating Church to sovereign undergoes elaborate scrutiny by Feofan Prokopovyč, apologist and theologian with Protestant leanings, who, in light of the abolition of the Patriarchate and the institution of the Holy Synod, affirms the principle of cuius regio eius et religio, openly challenging the position of the locum tenens Stefan Javors’kyj.

Download in PDF format

L’alimentazione halal e le sfide alla laïcité francese: il caso dei menù alternativi nelle mense scolastiche - ​ Ugo Gaudino

SOMMARIO: 1. Premessa metodologica - 2. Cenni storici sulle comunità musulmane francesi - 3. La re-invenzione di una tradizione? - 4. Mangiare halal a scuola: l’affaire di Chalon-sur-Saône - 5. Conclusioni.

Halal alimentation and the challenges against french laïcité: the request of alternative menu in the school canteens

ABSTRACT: The article will concern the debate about the balance between secularism and religious-driven prerogatives through a narrow focus on the diffusion of halal food in France. In particular, I will shed light on the increasing request of shari'a-compliant food by Muslims in some social spaces, for instance in the school canteens. My research will unfold its arguments in two sections. In the first one, I will address the recent development of halal market in France and try to frame the reasons of such burgeoning activities - revival of Islam or neoliberal marketing strategy? In the second part, I will consider the sentence of Dijon Administrative Tribunal, which in 2017 abolished the decision of the mayor of Chalon-sur-Saône of suppressing halal menu in the school canteens. The verdict might be read as an opinion favourable to Muslim’s prerogatives. Nonetheless, the rationale of the judgement does lie indeed in the defence of the “best interest of the child”, whereas the basic principles of French laicité were not put into discussion.

Download in PDF format

Il Giudice italiano e le Università Pontificie: un “rapporto” controverso - ​ Settimio Carmignani Caridi

SOMMARIO: 1. Premessa - 2. Significatio verborum - 3. Dove ha la propria sede la PUL? - 4. Che rapporto c’è tra la PUL e la Santa Sede? - 5. La docenza universitaria ecclesiastica è funzione ecclesiale? - 6. La Santa Sede si è vista riconoscere in sede internazionale la sua competenza sulle università ecclesiastiche e pontificie? - 7. Inquadramento della materia così ricostruita nella normativa pattizia - 8. Conclusioni.

The Italian judge and the Pontifical Universities: a controversial relationship

ABSTRACT: The article examines the juridical status of the Roman Pontifical Universities and the jurisprudence of the Supreme Court of Cassation regarding employment relationships with institutions dependent on the Holy See.

Download in PDF format

La Bielorussia alla ricerca della propria identità e il processo di confessionalizzazione dello Stato - ​ Giovanni Cimbalo

SOMMARIO: 1. Dal socialismo di Stato allo Stato confessionale - 2. L’Accordo di collaborazione con l’Esarcato della Chiesa ortodossa Russa in Bielorussia - 3. Le materie oggetto di accordo e la confessionalizzazione delle istituzioni e dello Stato - 4. Gli accordi con gli altri culti tradizionali - 5. Il prezzo dell’alleanza: la lotta alle nuove confessioni religiose attraverso la legge sulla libertà religiosa - 6. Alcune considerazioni finali.

Belarus in search of its identity and the process of confessionalisation of the State

ABSTRACT: The current piece analyzes the stages characterizing the transition from State socialism to State Confessionalism through the Collaboration Agreement between the Belorussian Government and the Exarcate of the Russian Orthodox Church in Belarus. The main subjects of the agreement and the confessionalisation process of the institutions are taken into account. The essay deals with the alteration of the basic functions of the Belorussian State, namely education, health services and assistancy to the segregating foundations, etc. Furthermore, the agreements with other traditional religious groups are relevant. In this regard, the law on religious freedom is mainly used to resist the spread of such new cults. The study is then finalized to highlight the existing link between the Russian Orthodox Church traditions and cultural heritage with the estabilishment of a national identity. This symbolic bond is then used to build the basis of a new State with strong religious features in sensitive matters such as the control over births, bridal affairs, cultural and social valuesin a nationalist and sovereignist key.

Download in PDF format

Cerimonia di consegna dei volumi degli «Scritti in memoria di Maria Cristina Folliero “Rigore e curiosità”» - ​ AA. VV. (G. D'angelo e altri) Giuseppe D'Angelo Sara Domianello Giuseppe Fauceglia Enzo Maria Marenghi

SOMMARIO: Presentazione - Interventi di G. Fauceglia (ordinario di Diritto commerciale nell’Università degli Studi di Salerno) e di G. D’Angelo (associato di Diritto ecclesiastico e canonico nell’Università degli Studi di Salerno) - Relazioni - E.M. Marenghi (ordinario di Diritto amministrativo, già Preside della Facoltà di Giurisprudenza dell’Università degli Studi di Salerno), L’esperienza di Maria Cristina Folliero nella Facoltà giuridica salernitana - S. Domianello (ordinario di Diritto ecclesiastico e canonico nell’Università degli Studi di Messina), Il pensiero di Maria Cristina Folliero nell’ambito degli studi di Diritto ecclesiastico e canonico - Intervento conclusivo di A. Vitale (già ordinario di Diritto ecclesiastico e canonico nell’Università degli Studi di Salerno).

Download in PDF format

Parere sulla applicabilità della normativa anticorruzione alle Fabbricerie - ​ Giuseppe Dalla Torre

1 - Si chiede un Parere sulla applicabilità alle Fabbricerie della normativa anticorruzione. La questione nasce da deliberazione dell’Autorità Nazionale Anticorruzione volta a orientare gli enti di diritto privato controllati e partecipati, direttamente e indirettamente, da pubbliche amministrazioni, e gli enti pubblici economici, nella applicazione della normativa in materia di prevenzione della corruzione e trasparenza di cui alla legge n. 190 del 2012. In particolare l’Autorità in questione ritiene che le Fabbricerie, come tipologia di ente giuridico, possano essere considerate come “ente di diritto privato in controllo pubblico” ai sensi dell’art. 24 bis, del D.L. 24 giugno 2014, convertito in Legge 11 agosto 2014, n. 114 (continua).

Opinion upon the applicability of the anti-corruption legislation at the “Fabbricerie”

ABSTRACT: The “Fabbricerie” do not fall into the category of “private-law entities under public control” pursuant to art. 24 bis of the D.L. n. 114 of 2014, and consequently they are not required to comply with the obligations set out in the legislation on the prevention of corruption and transparency. And this because: they are neither public entities nor private entities, but ecclesiastical entities sui generis, governed by a legal regime negotiated between Italy and Holy See, therefore unalterably unilaterally; their purpose is mainly and directly aimed to guarantee the serving the church and the cult, and therefore it is for purposes other than the public interest as per art. 24 bis of the D.L. n. 114 of 2014; the provision for the appointment of the administrators is not an expression of the supremacy of the public administration.

Download in PDF format

La codificazione per la Chiesa latina: attese e realizzazioni. Dobbiamo tornare alle Decretali? - ​ Giorgio Feliciani

SOMMARIO: 1. Il disegno riformatore di Giovanni XXIII e le direttive per la revisione del Codice approvate dal Sinodo dei vescovi del 1967 - 2. Un nuovo statuto per i fedeli - 3. Il principio di sussidiarietà - 4. Codice e Concilio - 5. Un cantiere aperto - 6. Un punto di non ritorno.

Codification for the Latin Church. Must we return to the Decretals?

It was during the Synod of Bishops in 1967 that the world episcopate declared their expectations regarding the revision of the Code of Canon Law. They formulated ten principles that should inspired it. Among them, particular attention was paid to those concerning the statute of the faithful and the principle of subsidiarity, critically evaluating the practical actualisation which they then received in the new Code. But, among bishops and the people of God there was also a by far more general expectation to see the very soul of the Council transfused into the Code. The opinions about its actual implementation are quite divergent, also because there is no lack of those who consider the legislative form of the codification poorly compatible with the nature of the law of the Church. However even the most severe critics recognise that the 1983 Code marks a transitional stage of great importance in the life of the Church.

Download in PDF format

I rapporti con l’Islam italiano: dalle proposte d’intesa al Patto nazionale - ​ Claudia Morucci

SOMMARIO: 1. Breve premessa - 2. L’ininterrotto dialogo tra il Governo e le comunità islamiche italiane - 3. Il “Patto di condivisione” della Città di Torino e il “Patto nazionale per un Islam italiano” - 4. L’Italia e le misure di contrasto al terrorismo - 5. Conclusione.

The relationship with Italian Islam: from the proposals of ‘Intesa’ to the ‘Patto nazionale

ABSTRACT: According to statistics, Muslims living in Italy are currently just over 1.6 million. However, despite this significant presence of Muslims on the national territory, the vast world of Islamic associations has not yet managed to sign an Intesa, an agreement that religious minorities can establish to regulate their relations with the Italian state. The reasons why Islam does not have an agreement are mainly two: the absence of an authoritative subject, representative of Italian Islam, able to act as an interlocutor with state institutions and the incompatibility between Islamic cultural values and those of a secular state. Nevertheless, covering all the stages of dialogue between the Italian government and the Islamic associations from the nineties until the conclusion of the Patto nazionale (2017), this work aims to show that the condition of legal vacuum depends on unfounded prejudices towards Islamic culture and on the lack of political will to come to terms with Islam.

Download in PDF format

UNESCO, Religious Freedoms and World Cultural Heritage in the Old City of Jerusalem: the line of fire between challenges, comparisons and new perspectives - ​ Clizia Franceschini

SUMMARY: 1. Introduction to the role of UNESCO in defining, respecting and implementing Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms: a general analysis - 2. The right to participate freely in cultural life: the specific UNESCO's involvement in the field of religious rights - 3. IHL Dimension linked to UNESCO's Legislative Powers to Protect the Cultural Heritage in the Event of Armed Conflict or Occupation - 4. UNESCO's Actions to Preserve the Cultural Heritage in Syria and Iraq: A comparative framework - 5. The Legal Status of Jerusalem and the management of the Holy Places: Jerusalem in a Nutshell - 6. UNESCO's past interventions in Jerusalem: a legal basis for future interventions - 7. The Mughrabi Gate Ascent - 8. The 2008 Action Plan for the Safeguarding of the Cultural Heritage of the Old City of Jerusalem - 9. UNESCO, Resolution 200 EX/PX/DR.25.2:“Occupied Palestine” - 10. Conclusions.

ABSTRACT: The current dissertation is mainly going to analyse the original contribution of UNESCO to the development of the concept of cultural rights through the proclamation and elaboration of normative instruments and strategies concerning the right to the protection of and access to the cultural (religious) heritage in contested areas. Since 1967, UNESCO has increasingly played a dominant role in the Old city of Jerusalem: it exercised its power in the field of the preservation of cultural heritage in a contested area, not only through practical plans, but also through legislative instruments and Resolutions. A peculiar political contest is still challenging the full exercise of its powers and the applicability of the main human rights treaty dealing with the preservation of cultural heritage in a contest of competing sovereignty. The essay, drawing on UNESCO's past restoration experiences in ancient (Aleppo, 1992) and post-conflict (Iraq, 2003) areas, focuses on the conciliation role that the Agency may potentially play in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

Download in PDF format

L’esercizio della potestà giudiziaria del fedele laico attraverso il prisma della Potestas gubernandi in Ecclesia. Sollecitazioni teologiche e canonistiche per una “Chiesa in uscita” - ​ Francesco Rea

SOMMARIO: 1. Premessa - 2. Fondamenti teorici della posizione del fedele laico nella Chiesa - 3. Riflessioni teologiche sulla potestas sacra nella Chiesa. Il concetto di ministerialità come spazio di inserimento per il Christifidelis nella missione ecclesiale - 4. Risvolti giuridici nell’ottica di una complementarietà tra munus e potestas - 5. Mitis Iudex Dominus Iesus e aperture a una più effettiva partecipazione del fedele laico alla potestà giudiziaria - 6. Giudice unico laico e collegio di laici: prospettive de iure condendo per un’esegesi evolutiva del can. 1421, § 2, C.i.c. - 7. Rilievi conclusivi: alcune potenzialità inespresse del Mitis Iudex Dominus Iesus?

The exercise of the judicial power by the lay faithful through the prism of Potestas gubernandi in Ecclesia. Theological and canonical solicitations for an “outgoing Church”

ABSTRACT: The more than thirty years since the II Vatican Council and the recent procedural reforms initiated by Pope Francis make very topical a reflection on the actual role that lay faithful can exercise within the Church. In particular, by virtue of the Sacrament of Baptism, that makes everyone “sons in the Son”, it seems ecclesiologically inconceivable that lay faithful can still suffer limitations from the point of view of participation in judicial power, especially in perspective of a now-acquired theory of potestas sacra, which, altough it all comes from God, does not require, for each office, the Sacrament of holy Order. The requirements of technical preparation and knowledge of law, the only parameters on which the ecclesiastical authority must be based on the choiche of the judges, impose a re-updating of the can. 1421, § 2, C.i.c. This norm is the only one that deals, in a very limited way, with the figure of the lay judge. Just the recent reform of Mitis Iudex Dominus Iesus, also considering the synodal context in which it has born, would be well matched with an inclusive re-evaluation of the lay faithful in exercise of a ministeriality which is nothing but a concrete expression of the participation to the only mission of the which all the People of God must become executor through the times.

Download in PDF format

Law and religion as a strategy in favor of profitable cultural osmosis: a wide look to civil law systems - ​ Antonio Fuccillo Francesco Sorvillo Ludovica Decimo

SUMMARY: 1. Together in diversity: law and religion in modern civil law systems - 2. The religious traditions in law and religion - 3. The religion and law osmosis in law-making processes - 4. The religion and law osmosis in jurisdiction - 5. As a strategy: the nomopoietic function of religions in the legal koinè.

Download in PDF format

Il diritto come mediazione fra saperi distinti. Perché il diritto non ha fatto un passo indietro di fronte alla scienza - ​ Lucia Corso

SOMMARIO: 1. Il diritto resiste alla scienza - 2. La scienza come criterio di legittimazione della norma giuridica - 3. Diritto come fenomeno normativo: incommensurabilità fra diritto e scienza - 4. Il diritto come super scienza - 4.1. Voracità processuale - 4.2. Verità giuridica e legittimazione dell’organo decidente - 4.3. Verità giuridica e falsificazione - 4.4. Margini del sindacato giudiziario - 5. Diritto come mediazione fra saperi distinti - 6. Conclusioni: diritto, scienza e gestione dell’incertezza.

Law as system which incorporates distinct epistemological methods. Why legal reasoning did not retreat before scientific knowledge

ABSTRACT: The central claim of this Article is that, despite the frequent references by legal acts to scientific knowledge, the scientific method has not supplanted or overshadowed the proper features of legal reasoning arising from the idea of law as an autonomous system of knowledge. In fact, just the opposite has occurred. It will be argued that the resistance of the legal at the scientific method can be explained on the basis of three distinct theories of law and legal reasoning: a) the first claims that law is a normative system which is incommensurable with science; b) the second qualifies law as a kind of superscience which grounds legitimacy to science itself; c) the third defines law as a normative system which accepts and incorporates forms of knowledges which the scientific method normally rejects.

Download in PDF format

La riforma del Terzo settore e gli enti ecclesiastici: un rischio, un costo o un’opportunità? - ​ Andrea Perrone Venerando Marano

SOMMARIO: 1. La riforma del Terzo settore - 2. Enti ecclesiastici e riforma del Terzo settore - 3. Le condizioni per l’applicazione del regime del Terzo settore agli enti ecclesiastici - 3.1. Il regolamento - 3.2. Il patrimonio destinato - 3.3. La tenuta di scritture contabili separate - 4. Le possibili soluzioni organizzative - 4.1. Il “ramo” dell’ente ecclesiastico - 4.2. Il “gruppo” dell’ente ecclesiastico - 5. Una rete associativa per gli enti del Terzo settore ecclesiastici?

The reform of non-profit organizations and Church bodies: a cost, a risk or an opportunity?

ABSTRACT: While many institutional activities of Church bodies fall within the scope of the recent reform of Italian law on non-profit organizations ("NPOs"), the specific features of Church bodies prevent from a straightforward application of the new regime. Therefore, the Code for the Third Sector and the Act on Social Enterprises allow Church bodies to access the tax exemptions and the other benefits provided to NPOs as far as they comply with a set of conditions aimed at bridging the differences between Church bodies and secular NPOs. The paper (1) discusses in details these conditions, (2) offers a critical evaluation of costs, risks, and opportunities related to the new regime, and (3) suggests possible organizational structures to comply with the current system.

Download in PDF format

Il ministero del Lettorato: prospettive storico-canoniche e sguardo sulla legislazione particolare della Conferenza Episcopale Italiana - ​ Luciano Labanca

SOMMARIO: 1. Premessa - 2. Evoluzione storica del lettorato: da ordine minore a ministero istituito - 3. Normativa canonica universale sul ministero del lettorato: dal CIC del 1983 a oggi - 4. Il diritto particolare della Conferenza episcopale italiana sul ministero del lettore: dal 1973 a oggi - 5. Discussione sull’accesso della donna al ministero del lettorato - 6. Conclusioni.

The ministry of lector: historical-canonical perspectives and Italian Episcopal Conference particular law

ABSTRACT: The paper intends to analyze the ministry of lector, describing its historical evolution from the minor order to institued ministry, after the motu proprio Ministeria quaedam of Pope Paul VI (1972). Then, the autor proposes an overview of its status in Canon and liturgical laws. Next, the particular law of the Italian Episcopal Conference is analyzed, and, finally, the possibility of the opening of the ministry of lector for women is discussed.

Download in PDF format

Ordinamento statuale e confessioni religiose. La politica delle fonti di diritto in Italia - ​ Roberto Mazzola

SOMMARIO: 1. Primo quadro: magazzino normativo – 2. - Secondo quadro: analisi storico-giuridica – 3. Terzo quadro: il futuro.

State and religious organisations. The Politics of the sources of law

ABSTRACT: The paper intends to verify if religious freedom in the Italian legal system is undergoing a crisis. In particular, is the concept of religious freedom of the Constituent Assembly still good? Is it necessary to reform the regulation of religious freedom? Similar questions are posed with regard to the current relationship between State and religions.

Download in PDF format

Símbolos religiosos y paradojas del franquismo a la luz de la Ley de Memoria Histórica - ​ Manuel Alenda Salinas Matilde Pineda Marcos

SUMARIO: 1. Planteamiento de la cuestión - 2. El catolicismo-nacionalista de ciertos símbolos evocadores de lo religioso - 3. ¿Los símbolos religioso-franquistas pueden permanecer en ámbitos públicos? - 3.1. Supuesto en que el símbolo religioso no ha de tenerse por vestigio franquista - 3.2. Supuesto en que el símbolo ha de tenerse por vestigio franquista - 4. Consideraciones conclusivas.

ABSTRACT: The present article argues if, under the interpretation and application of the so-called Historical Memory Law, Franco’s regimen would have set the basis to divest itself as part of the Catholicism that characterized it, in terms of having some symbols that originally would have been considered religious and now they cease to be so, historically and inevitably, at least in a retrospective point of view. In other terms, for the current time to impose a type of victim, although final of Franco’s regimen in the manner of, as a paradox, for some religious symbols to cease to be, without any other possibility for its political use as far as ‘semel francoist semper francoist’ can no longer recover that religious value. This matter, whether it refers, principally to the “Cruces de los Caídos” it can also be argued for it to attain the crucifix and the Virgin Mary located in public places by order of the dictatorial regimen.

Download in PDF format

Toccare con mano i nodi dell’integrazione (a proposito di saluti “proibiti” e divieto di discriminazione) - ​ Angelo Licastro

SOMMARIO: 1. Le possibili implicazioni religiose di una “stretta di mano” - 2. Il caso sottoposto all’esame dei giudici svedesi - 3. La pronunzia del 15 agosto 2018, n. 51, del Tribunale del lavoro svedese e la questione della ricorrenza di una “pratica religiosa” meritevole di tutela - 4. (segue) La verifica dei presupposti di una “discriminazione indiretta” - 5. L’esperienza d’Oltreoceano - 6. Identità religiosa e (dis)uguaglianza di genere - 7. La diversa incidenza, nella fattispecie esaminata, del divieto di discriminazione per motivi religiosi e del principio della parità di genere - 8. Conclusioni: la libertà religiosa della lavoratrice e i margini lasciati alle scelte di politica aziendale della società.

Dealing with the contentious points of the integration (about “forbidden” greetings and principle of non-discrimination)

ABSTRACT: Some Islamic believers adhere to a rule of behavior coming from a particular reading of the traditions concerning the life of Muhammad, so they do not shake hands with people of the other sex outside their own restricted family circle. The present paper analyzes the potential impact of such a choice, if it is carried out in the work context and it infringes specific internal company rules, which require employees to not discriminate against customers on the basis of sex. The Author, in accordance with a recent decision of the Swedish Labor Court, affirms that the limitation of the freedom of the worker can be considered a case of indirect discrimination for religious reasons. However, demanding that the woman abstains from shaking hands with persons of her own sex, as suggested by the Court, is not required by the principle of gender equality, and is not coherent with the very personal nature of the act, according to the Author.

Download in PDF format

Violenza organizzata e appartenenza religiosa. Il caso dell’Isis - ​ Roberto Cornelli

SOMMARIO: 1. La religione c’entra? Una premessa culturalista - 2. La violenza organizzata nel mondo e la centralità della guerra siriana - 3. L’ISIS: dall’Iraq alla Siria e recenti sviluppi - 4. Potere o religione? - 5. Chi sono i militanti jihadisti occidentali - 6. Attratti dall’ISIS - 7. Conclusioni.

Organized violence and religious affiliation: the case of Isis

ABSTRACT: This paper seeks to address the crucial issue of organized violence from a cultural perspective analyzing the case of ISIS, tipically considered as religious group. It intends to elaborate some of the key questions of the debate on the links between religion and violence. The religious nature of ISIS will be disputed throughout its birth and expansion during the U.S. invasion of Iraq and the Syrian conflict: more specifically, the paper aims to shed some lights on the grounds underlying the decision of western foreign fighters and Jihadists to join with or refer to a group of fanatics fighting in the faraway land of Syria. The research methodology is based on an interactionist approach on violence in order to avoid focusing on psychopathological (‘they are violent because they are mad’) or ethical-religious aspects (‘they are violent because they are driven by a bad religion’): on the contrary this paper aims to investigate Jihadist violence in its relational and symbolic aspects, as part of a socio-cultural way of life. In the end, the impact of this approach on possible prevention programs will be touched on briefly.

Download in PDF format

Atheism and the Principle of Laïcité in France. A Shifting Process of Mutual Adaptation - ​ Francesco Alicino

SUMMARY: 1. Introduction - 2. The Vertical and Horizontal Influences - 3. Atheism, laïcité and Church - 4. Atheism, laïcité and Islam - 5. Today’s Popular Sources of Atheism - 6. Conclusion.

ABSTRACT: With this article, the Author outlines the legal issues involving the atheism in France, analysing them in the light of the principle of laïcité. France has a long history of criticism of religion. Many philosophes of the Enlightenment, for example, have provided the classical writings in this field. In this sense, they were able to aliment two major streams of thought of the magmatic French atheism: one is based on the horizontal influences arising from the effect of increasing worldwide travel with the discovery that people do not necessary share the same views and beliefs about the nature of human being; the other is centred on vertical arguments bubbling up from the past in a very form of scepticism and realism. With its multi-faceted and articulated view, the French atheism has also been promoted by a number of movements devoted to arguing the case for non-belief and for its political expression in laïcité. In this manner, the Author tries to demonstrate that, since the Great Revolution and during the long history of the French constitutional system, laïcité de combat and atheism has been influencing each other in a constantly shifting process of mutual adaptation.

Download in PDF format

OGM e ostie a basso contenuto di glutine. La comunione dei fedeli celiaci: una questione ancora aperta - ​ Tiziana Di Iorio

SOMMARIO: 1. Le norme sulla Santa comunione dei fedeli celiaci - 2. Le recenti linee guida emanate su richiesta di Papa Francesco - 3. Il pane mere triticeus come insostituibile elemento dell’Eucarestia - 4. La fonte della liturgia cattolica sul divieto dell’uso di ostie gluten free come materia eucaristica: il pane dell’ultima cena - 5. Il glutine come parte del pane eucaristico - 6. Il fedele celiaco e la Santa comunione tra ostie a basso contenuto di glutine, comunione sub sola specie vini e comunione spirituale - 7. L’uso di organismi geneticamente modificati (OGM) nell’Eucarestia e la genuinità della materia eucaristica - 8. Conclusioni.

GMO and low gluten host. The communion of the celiacs faithful: an open question

ABSTRACT: Celiac disease is an autoimmune disorder triggered by gluten in susceptible individuals. Currently, there is no specific medical treatment for celiac disease. The only treatment for this disorder is lifelong adherence to a gluten-free diet. Catholic Church affirmed that bread, to be valid material for the Eucharist, must be made of wheat, must contain enough gluten for breadmaking and must be free of foreign matter. In order to meet the needs of those who suffer from the celiac disease, it has introduced the validity of low gluten. The Circular Letter issued at the request of Pope Francis has not changed the Holy Communion of the celiac faithful. Nevertheless, the document also decided that Eucharistic matter made with OGM could be considered valid matter. The Roman rite finds its theological source in the elements of Eucarist by Jesus instituted in the Last Easter Supper. The sources, however, do not indicate the matter of the bread offered at the Last Supper. So can we say that it was really made of wheat? The solution to this enigma is very important. In fact, it could open up new horizons on Eucharistic matter and on the validity of the gluten free hosts.

Download in PDF format

Multiculturalism, multireligiosity and relations between the State and religious organizations - ​ Marco Parisi

Summary: 1. Introduction - 2. Constitutional project of ecclesiastical politics and cultural resistance to a correct interpretation of the fundamental provisions of freedom - 3. Secularity of the legal system, religious pluralism and human freedoms.

ABSTRACT: The problems that derive from the growing multicultural and multi-religious characterization of our society raise a number of questions regarding the difficulties encountered in identifying rules of coexistence that could be genuinely respectful of the ideal and spiritual dimension of the human person. In particular, it is in question the ability of the system of bilateral agreements between the State and the religious organizations to really enhance the individual religiosity, which is constitutionally protected in its instrumentality for the promotion and growth of the human being. Several doubts also concern the discretionary and political selection, exercised by public authorities, of religious organizations deserving an access to bilateral regulation of relationships. In a more and more plural and heterogeneous social reality, the exclusion from the special legislation of the newly established spiritual groups in the country does not seem to be respectful of a neutral and correct interpretation of the constitutional dictate.

Download in PDF format

La convinzione della nullità del proprio matrimonio: riflessi sull’ordinamento processuale - ​ Salvatore Berlingò

SOMMARIO: 1. I precedenti e le premesse per un cambio di prospettiva - 2. Il “discernimento” delle convinzioni dei soggetti sulla nullità del proprio matrimonio alla luce del paradigma della discontinuità nella continuità - 3. L’indagine giuridico-pastorale propedeutica all’introduzione dei giudizi sulla nullità del matrimonio - 4. La predisposizione di un ambiente processuale favorevole al vaglio delle “prove di coscienza” - 5. Gli apparati giudiziari al servizio delle convinzioni di coscienza delle parti - 6. L’intento di non turbare le convinzioni di coscienza dei conviventi in buona fede e il ruolo delle direttive extra-giudiziali sul possibile ricorso a soluzioni epicheietiche.

The convictions of the spouses on the validity of marriage: incidences on the process

ABSTRACT: The trial reforms introduced by the present Pontificate and the emanation of the Apostolic Exhortation ‘Amoris Laetitia’, in respect of the criterion of “graduality” that inspires the itinerary of the “Church in exit” traced by Pope Francis, do not bring substantial novelty about how “to discern” the convictions of the parties on the validity of marriage. They put into effect, nevertheless, a change of perspective, or rather a different point of view from which to consider these convictions, while still respecting the declarative nature of the nullity judgments, as distinct from legal and pastoral directives on possible epikeia solutions.

Download in PDF format

Modes of neutrality in the ECtHR jurisprudence related to religious matters: some critical remarks - ​ Alice Ollino

SUMMARY: 1. Introduction - 2. The meaning of State neutrality: some conceptual clarifications - 3. State’s neutrality vis-à-vis religious organizations: neutrality as absence of interference - 4. State’s neutrality vis-à-vis public education: neutrality as objectivity - 5. State neutrality vis-à-vis religious symbols in the public sphere: neutrality as exclusion of religion - 6. ‘Reversed’ patters of neutrality: the disruptive effect of Lautsi v. Italy - 7. Concluding remarks: decoding the patterns of State neutrality in the jurisprudence of the ECtHR.

ABSTRACT: This contribution discusses the notion of State neutrality in the jurisprudence of the European Court of Human Rights. State neutrality has become increasingly relevant in the rulings of the ECtHR concerning religious freedom, with the Court explicitly resorting to the idea that States should act as neutral and impartial organizers of religious life within their community. Yet, the conception of State neutrality developed by the Court is inconsistent and often gives rise to criticism. By exploring the Court’s main jurisprudence in the context of religious disputes, religious education in public education, and the display of religious symbols in public spaces, this contribution seeks to disentangle the different understandings of neutrality employed by the Court and to critically engage with them.

Download in PDF format

La controvertida prohibición de la blasfemia en la Constitución de la República de Irlanda - ​ José Ramón Polo Sabau

SUMARIO: 1. Introducción - 2. La prohibición de la blasfemia en el marco de una Constitución de clara inspiración católica - 3. El cuestionamiento de una norma de tan dudoso encaje en el sistema constitucional de derechos y libertades - 3.1. Las críticas en general al régimen constitucional de las confesiones religiosas - 3.2. La controversia específica en torno a la prohibición de la blasfemia en la Constitución irlandesa - 4. Algunas conclusiones y una razonable expectativa.

The controversial offence of blasphemy in the Irish Constitution

ABSTRACT: As recently as June 2018 the Irish Government has approved a referendum to remove the offence of blasphemy from the Constitution; the referendum will be held in October this year. This paper briefly examines the historical and legal backgrounds of this controversial prohibition that survived the 1972 reform of the constitutional provisions in the field of Church and State that, among other aspects, conferred a special position to the Catholic Church, and it does so in order to underline the importance and the potential consequences of the proposed reform in case of an affirmative vote in the upcoming referendum. For this analysis the author gives prior consideration to the fundamental meaning and scope of the constitutional provisions currently in force in the area of Law and Religion and, once this framework is summarized, the paper turns to reflect primarily on the legal and judicial developments that have taken place in the last decades relating the offence of blasphemy in Irish Law.

Download in PDF format

Ultimissime dalla giurisprudenza in materia di reati culturalmente motivati - ​ Fabio Basile

SOMMARIO 1. Considerazioni introduttive - 2. La definizione dottrinale di “reato culturalmente motivato”, e le sue “sotto-categorie” prasseologiche - 3. La giurisprudenza relativa a reati a elevata offensività - 4. La giurisprudenza relativa a reati a bassa offensività - 5. La sentenza Cass. n. 29613 del 2018. - 6. Verso un test culturale come architrave motivazionale? - 7. Considerazioni finali.

Latest News from Jurisprudence on Culturally Motivated Crimes

ABSTRACT:  The author, after having clarified the notion of culturally motivated crime consolidated in doctrine, analyzes the recent Italian jurisprudence on the topic, representing the general coordinates provided by the Court of Cassation to the interpreter in the presence of this type of crimes.

Download in PDF format

L’iter delle intese sui rapporti Stato-confessioni ristretto fra discrezionalità politica e insicurezza presunta - ​ Fortunato Freni

SOMMARIO: 1. Il ruolo di Parlamento e Governo nella modifica del Concordato lateranense e nell’elaborazione delle intese con le confessioni acattoliche - 2. La prassi instaurata per l’iter di stipulazione delle intese - 3. La discrezionalità del Governo all’avvio delle trattative e il caso dell’UAAR - 4. Il concetto di confessione religiosa parte di un’intesa - 5. I limiti e le garanzie costituzionali nell’uso delle intese - 6. Anomalie tra normativa bilaterale e normativa unilaterale: intese-fotocopia e diritto comune “para-pattizio” - 7. La differenza fra le trattative per un’intesa e la negoziazione normativa - 8. La presunta minaccia del fondamentalismo religioso e il senso d’insicurezza instillato a fini politici.

The proceding of agreements on relations between State and religious denominations is restricted between political discretion and alleged insecurity

ABSTRACT: The present essay analyzes the procedure aimed at stipulating agreements on relations between the state and religious denominations considering the new elements introduced by the UAAR case. The Italian Union of Atheists and Agnostics is the protagonist of a long-standing case law case, because the Government has rejected the request for access to negotiations that allow to verify in concrete whether the conditions exist for concluding an agreement pursuant to in the third paragraph of the article 8 of the Constitution

Download in PDF format

Diritto ed estrema ingiustizia. Una riflessione a partire dalle pagine di Fred Uhlman - ​ Leonardo Mellace

SOMMARIO: 1. Introduzione: Il problema dell’estrema ingiustizia ne La Trilogia del ritorno – 2. La deferenza al diritto nella prospettiva di Uhlman – 3. Tortura: brevi riflessioni a partire dalle pagine de La trilogia.

Law and extreme injustice. A reflection starting from Fred Uhlman’s pages

ABSTRACT: This article adopts the perspective of the “Law and Literature” studies in order to focus on the terrible experience of the Holocaust that wracked Europe during the first half of the twentieth century. The theoretical and legal analysis is developed starting from the pages written by Fred Uhlman. Literature can help to move on to an in-depth debate that – from the issue of the violation of human rights – is to be carried out into the relationship between law and morality. The extreme injustice, the banality of evil and the radicalism of fascist ideologies represent the main themes this article starts from.

Download in PDF format

Le dinamiche concordatarie tra Santa Sede e Stati islamici - ​ Raffaele Santoro

SOMMARIO: 1. Il concordato nelle dinamiche delle relazioni tra Chiesa cattolica e Stati islamici - 2. Concordato e libertà religiosa nei Paesi islamici - 3. Gli accordi bilaterali sottoscritti dalla Santa Sede in questi speciali “territori di missione” - 4. La tutela delle minoranze religiose nella Dichiarazione di Al-Azhar e la possibile apertura di nuove frontiere delle dinamiche concordatarie.

The concordat dynamics between Holy See and Islamic State

ABSTRACT: The article analyzes the concordat dynamics between Holy See and Islamic States developed after the Second Vatican Council. The concordat, in its various forms, is the main instrument through which is regulated the system of relations between States and Catholic Church. Its use has been tested successfully in various Islamic States, and sometimes even with heterogeneous formulas, because of differences that distinguish the individual systems, trying to translate the concepts of autonomous of Church and collaboration with States in forms legal acceptable to Muslim tradition countries. The exhortations in the Al-Azhar Declaration are directly connected with the possible development of bilateral activities between Holy See and other Islamic countries and this can also strengthen the peace among peoples and the interfaith dialogue.

Download in PDF format

“Si appellatio mere dilatoria evidenter appareat”: alcune note a margine dei cann. 1680, § 2, e 1687, § 4, C.i.c. post Mitis Iudex Dominus Iesus - ​ Francesco Rea

SOMMARIO: 1. Il background di una riforma “missionaria” - 2. Insidie ermeneutiche della clausola - 3. Esegesi soggettive e oggettive: limiti applicativi - 4. Una versione mediata: la valutazione sull’appello come indagine de merito causæ - 5. L’applicazione della clausola al processo ordinario … - 6. … e al processus brevior - 7. Considerazioni conclusive.

“Si appellatio mere dilatoria evidenter appareat”: some considerations on the sidelines of cann. 1682, § 2 and 1687, § 4 C.i.c. after the motu proprio Mitis Iudex Dominus Iesus

ABSTRACT: The paper aims to analyze the problems underlying the clause that states “si appellatio mere dilatoria evidenter appareat”, introduced with the Motu proprio “Mitis Iudex Dominus Iesus” with whom Pope Francis has reformed the processes of marriage nullity in 2015. Beyond the mere terminologic matter, which has also committed the doctrine, given the imperfect clarity of the terms of which the clause is composed, what is at stake is the right of appeal granted to the losing party following a decision “pro nullitate matrimonii”. Legislative innovation must be lowered whithin a broader field of reform, where it’s called to interface with the background of ordinary process and of the new processus brevior, that has the primary goal to chase after the speed-up of processes. The risk of subjectivism in which the judges could fall, focusing on the mere intentions of the appellant subject or on the simple reasons given, and not giving rise to a complete judgment where to reach moral certainty, should be avoided in order to safeguard the aspiration of justice that canon law can not not have, and that precise connotations in terms of faith have only to contribute increasing.

Download in PDF format

“It is (not) a piece of cake”: libertà di espressione e politiche antidiscriminatorie in America. Note a margine del caso Masterpiece Cakeshop, Ltd. v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission - ​ Luca P. Vanoni

SOMMARIO: 1. Introduzione - 2. Tra free speech e free exercise clauses: la libertà di coscienza nella giurisprudenza della Corte suprema (cenni) - 3. Una discriminazione nella discriminazione? Una decisione che non risolve il dilemma - 4. Kicking the can down the road: l’arte di non decidere e le dissenting/concurring opinions del caso Masterpiece Cakeshop - 5. (segue) a) l’opinion del giudice Thomas - 6. (segue) b) uno sguardo sul futuro: due (ipotetici) orientamenti prevalenti - 7. Dal saluto alla bandiera alle torte nuziali: libertà e tolleranza nella società plurale contemporanea.

ABSTRACT: The paper examines the clash between public accommodations laws and freedoms of speech and religion in America at the light of the recent decision of the U.S. Supreme Court Masterpiece Cakeshop Ltd., v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission. The case deals with the refusal of a Colorado’s bakery to provide a wedding cake to a gay couple based on the owner's religious beliefs. After explaining the decision of the Court and the position of the U.S. Supreme Court Justices in their dissenting and concurring opinions, the paper addresses the claim of freedom of speech and of the tolerance principle in the pluralistic age.

Download in PDF format

Ordinamento giuridico e Diritto canonico: il contributo strutturante di Santi Romano - ​ Paolo Gherri

SOMMARIO: 1. Premessa - 2. Il Diritto come legittimazione - 3. La corrispondenza tra istituzione e ordinamento - 4. La terzietà del Diritto - 5. La non-necessarietà del legislatore affinché si abbia vero Diritto - 6. Per concludere.

Legal Order and Canon law: The Structuring Contribution of Santi Romano

ABSTRACT: The contribution of the State’s System Theory of Santi Romano is decisive for illustrating and protecting the singularities of Canon Law without jeopardizing its intrinsic juridical nature, rather, by confirming it precisely because of the “institutional” nature of the Church. The substantial contributions that "L’ordinamento giuridico" offers to the systematic and dogmatic understanding of Canon Law are four: law as legitimacy, the conformity between institution and legal system, the neutrality of the law, the non-necessity of the Legislator in order to have true law.

Download in PDF format

Rilevanza pubblica delle comunità religiose nella dimensione giuridica europea - ​ Pasquale Lillo

SOMMARIO: 1. La presenza religiosa nella sfera pubblica - 2. La libertà religiosa collettiva nella CEDU - 3. La condizione giuridica delle confessioni religiose nel diritto della UE - 4. Identità confessionali e identità nazionali europee - 5. Il ruolo “pubblico” delle istituzioni religiose negli Stati europei - 6. In particolare: a) la rilevanza costituzionale dei soggetti confessionali in Germania - 7. Segue: b) la condizione giuridica delle confessioni religiose in Italia.

Public relevance of religious communities in the European legal dimension

The religious phenomenon appears relevant both on an individual level and on a social level. In many cases religious experience, on the one hand, helps to draw the personal identity of the subject; on the other, it is an element that characterizes various aspects of civil society, up to the influence of the political and institutional dynamics of many contemporary state systems. This paper intends to demonstrate that the religious phenomenon does not appear confined only in the strictly private sphere, but lives and manifests itself also in the public dimension. This approach seems to be confirmed, among other things, by the new public role that religious communities are progressively taking on in the European legal sphere, as well as within individual state systems in Europe. From the analysis of the rules in force both at the European and national level, this work therefore derives a significant legal recognition of the public relevance of religions and religious communities that are direct institutional expression, paying particular attention to the experience gained in the German law and in the Italian legal system.

Download in PDF format

Il cammino della Chiesa per una rinnovata dottrina sociale: dal diritto di proprietà ai diritti sacri alla terra, alla casa, al lavoro - ​ Antonino Mantineo

SOMMARIO: 1. La storia della dottrina sociale nella storia della Chiesa – 2. Dal diritto (esclusivo) di proprietà al riconoscimento dei diritti del lavoratore – 3. La questione sociale diventa questione universale – 4. Contatti tra la dottrina sociale e le teorie politiche del lavoro – 5. I tre diritti “sacri” per (re)inventare una nuova dottrina sociale.

The Church’s path for an updated social doctrine: from the right to property to the sacred rights to land, housing and work

ABSTRACT: The essay analyzes the historical and juridical development of the Catholic Church’s social doctrine, from the teaching of Pope Leo XIII to the teaching of Pope Francis. Paying attention to the fundamental issues of the social justice is at the core of the existence and the mission of the Church. Nowdays, Pope Francis changed the emphasis of the official social doctrine, calling for a poor Church at the service of the poor and the Earth. This updated social doctrine is founded on the joyful announcement of the Gospel.

Download in PDF format

The legal status of Jerusalem in the State of Israel - ​ Myriam Lucia Di Marco

SUMMARY: 1. Introduction - 2. Background and Laws - 3. Legal Issues - 4. Future outlook.

Abstract: Jerusalem is the most important city in the world, the Centre of the three greatest religions. It is the Capital of the State of Israel for some, the capital of the State of Palestine for others and for others still a corpus separatum under international control. Everyone wants Jerusalem, and so they contest it, creating political and legislative unrest. These disturbances give rise to violence from both groups of people that live there. In this brief dissertation, we retrace the key historical points and problems associated with the legal status of this city, from the first decades of the twentieth century, to understand that the problem lies in the claim of ownership of this City.

Download in PDF format

Postfazione alla seconda edizione del volume di Piero Bellini, Principi di diritto ecclesiastico - ​ Sergio Lariccia

SOMMARIO: 1. Un piccolo volume destinato a uso degli studenti universitari e dei candidati ai concorsi pubblici (carriera direttiva) - 2. Il diritto ecclesiastico negli anni settanta - 3. Sette capitoli, inseriti in due parti e un’Appendice, sulla Natura dei Patti lateranensi.

Download in PDF format

Il Codice del terzo settore: punto di arrivo o di partenza per la palingenesi degli enti religiosi? - ​ Antonino Mantineo

SOMMARIO: 1. Riordino o riforma del Terzo Settore? - 2. Il contributo che possono offrire gli ecclesiasticisti e i canonisti alla riflessione - 3. La traiettoria: dalla legislazione bilaterale sugli enti cattolici al diritto comune sugli enti religiosi - 4. L’art. 20 Cost.: una lettura rinnovata in una prospettiva sistemica - 5. La legge n. 222 del 1985 rimane apripista della legislazione statale in ottica promozionale e pluralista - 6. Intese dello Stato con le confessioni e collegamento/coincidenza tra le attività di religione o di culto e le attività “diverse” - 7. Superamento “di fatto” della specialità della legislazione bilaterale sugli enti religiosi - 8. Alcune osservazioni critiche sul Codice del Terzo Settore - 9. Un diritto comune sugli enti religiosi nell’ottica dell’interesse generale? - 10. Una nuova mission per gli enti cattolici sollecitata dalla Chiesa di Papa Francesco.

The Third Sector Code: arrival point or starting point for the religious bodies’ palingenesis?

ABSTRACT: Adopted on July 2017, the Third Sector Code promotes social groups to guarantee the constitutional principles of pluralism, participation, social solidarity, substantial equality. The essay analyses what are the most important innovations and the critical issues of Third Sector’s reform, in the law and religion’s perspective and in the canon law’s perspective. Indeed, this legal reform raises fundamental questions, involving Third Sector bodies, that are, at the same time, religious bodies, such as the importance to have in our legal system a general law for religious bodies. Furthermore, Pope Francis’ teaching recalls an ethic dimension in the economic activities for the Catholic bodies.

Download in PDF format

“A chiare lettere - Confronti” • Senatus mala bestia. Considerazioni estemporanee sui ricorrenti tentativi di riforma della Curia Romana - ​ Francesco Zanchini

SOMMARIO: 1. Premessa - 2. Evoluzione burocratico-confessionista dell’impero di Costantino fino a Teodosio - 3. Qualche riflessione sull’attualità.

Download in PDF format

Le mutilazioni genitali femminili come reato di genere? Un’analisi delle norme europee alla luce del concetto di violenza - ​ Lucia Bellucci

SOMMARIO: 1. Introduzione – 2. Le mutilazioni genitali femminili come atto di violenza nelle norme e nei documenti europei degli anni 2000 – 3. Escissione e abuso/brutalità/violenza: binomi appropriati e inevitabili? – 4. L’escissione, il dolore e la sua reinterpretazione – 5. Il rapporto dell’escissione con la comunità, la famiglia e il matrimonio – 6. La Convenzione di Istanbul, le norme francesi e i rischi per la libertà religiosa – 7. Considerazioni conclusive.

Female Genital Mutilation as a Gender-Based Crime? (An Analysis of the European Norms in Light of the Concepts of Violence and Religious Freedom)

ABSTRACT: Female genital mutilations (FGM) are ancient practices, which are widespread in several geographical areas, and particularly in Africa. The conflict between customary norms and state legal systems, which arises because FGM violate fundamental rights like the right to physical integrity, health, and non-discrimination based on gender/ethnicity/culture, discloses the dialectic between two normative universes; these universes are conceptually distant with regard to the priority given to the individual and the group. Focusing on the reasons related to female genital cutting (FGC), which consists of the ablation, to differing degrees, of female genital organs, this article, argues that the link that European norms establish between FGM and violence, abuse or brutality comes into conflict with the reasons why migrants perpetuate FGC. Therefore, the way gender is mainstreamed into European norms on FGM can have negative effects, which concern courts’ implementation of these norms and migrants’ social inclusion. Furthermore, this article claims that focusing on health instead of gender equality may prove more effective for the eradication of FGM. Through an analysis of French law, it also suggests that the way the national law is adapted to conform to the Istanbul Convention, may represent a danger to religious freedom.

Download in PDF format

Luci e ombre di un documento controverso: la Correctio Filialis de Haeresibus Propagatis. Alcuni profili di diritto pubblico della Chiesa - ​ Domenico Bilotti

SOMMARIO: 1. Una premessa circa il contesto e le motivazioni della lettera al Pontefice - 2. La Correctio Filialis de Haeresibus Propagatis: punto di arrivo o di inizio di un dibattito? Antecedenti storici e parallelismi da precisare nelle argomentazioni degli estensori - 3. Un bersaglio polemico non sorprendente: l’Esortazione Amoris Laetitia. Questioni pastorali e contrapposizioni tra visioni diverse sul diritto della Chiesa - 4. Lo stylus del Pontificato. Temi giuridici e prospettive future per lo studio dell’ordo iuris ecclesiae: prime conclusioni.

Lights and shadows of a controversial document: the "Correctio filialis de haeresibus propagatis". Some outlines in Public Canon Law

ABSTRACT: The aim of this essay is to study and to analyze the current debate about recent Pope Francis’s propositions and affirmations regarding the Roman catholic doctrine and the concrete development of religious marriages in secular societies. One of the most important documents disputing the latest reforms and measures could be considered the so called “Correctio Filialis de Haeresibus Propagatis” that is intended to be a sort of manifesto of dissatisfaction and disappointment against the renewal of a comprehensive and tolerant approach in Canon Law’s rules concerning the status of divorced people and the assumed “irregular” civil unions. In spite of underlining some important aspects, probably not completely deepened by the Pope, that document at the same time undervalues the conceptual efforts to make the doctrine adequate to answer to a typical sense of restlessness in our time, even from a legal point of view.

Download in PDF format

Fondamento, logica e contenuto dell’obbligo della partecipazione eucaristica festiva - ​ Massimo del Pozzo

SOMMARIO: 1. La celebrazione del giorno del Signore - 2. L’ascendenza e lo sviluppo dell’obbligo - 3. Dalle origini del cristianesimo alle prime disposizioni canoniche - 4. La concezione del precetto nella canonistica classica - 5. Dalla disciplina tridentina alla codificazione piano benedettina - 6. L’attuale regolamentazione normativa - 7. La genesi dei canoni - 8. Il contenuto delle disposizioni codiciali - 9. Gli sviluppi e le indicazioni successive - 10. Il fondamento e la logica della partecipazione eucaristica - 11. La “sostanzialità” della prescrizione celebrativa - 12. L’incentivo e la riscoperta della pratica domenicale.

The Foundation, Logic and Content of the Eucharistic Observance of the Precept Regarding Sundays and Holy Days of Obligation

Abstract: This article examines the foundation and ratio of the eucharistic observance of the precept regarding Sundays and holy days of obligation, beginning with an overview of the question within both canonical tradition and current normative logic The historical-conceptual excursus highlights the maine phases of the formation of ecclesiastical discipline, while the analysis of current regulations demonstrates the continuity of normative provisions and eventual refinements. The dimension of justice manifests, above all, the social and institutional value of the precept, while the essential and particular characteristics of Christian holidays are also related to the communal and sacramental nature of the celebration. The logic behind the precept corresponds, then, to the solidarity, historicity, rationality and humanity of its observance. The regard for the “centrality of the Mass” leads to a respect for the substantiality and integrity of the good that is due. The incentive for and rediscovery of the Sunday practice depend primarily on catechetical and formative activity, but cannot be separated from juridical and directive contributions or the responsibility of members of the faithful and pastors.

Download in PDF format

Libertà di culto e diversità religiosa nelle carceri inglesi - ​ Jacopo Paffarini

SOMMARIO: 1. Premessa - 2. La disciplina dell’esercizio della fede nei penitenziari inglesi - 3. La diversità delle fedi in carcere e il ruolo delle community chaplaincies - 4. Il carcere come spazio multi-religioso e i nodi irrisolti dall’Equality Act del 2010 - 5. La discriminazione per motivi religiosi nella giurisprudenza inglese e gli obblighi di prestazione a carico della pubblica amministrazione.

Freedom of worship and Religious Diversity in English Prisons

ABSTRACT: This article aims to highlight different aspects of the practice of faith in the British prison system. While the 1952 Prison Act gave a preeminent position to the chaplains of the Church of England, in the last decades multi-faith spaces of worship and spiritual-care groups have multiplied. Furthermore, ‘community chaplaincies’ and volunteers are active players in rehabilitation programs, especially in preventing recidivism, which is higher among ethnic and religious minorities. Both the Human Rights Act of 1998 and the Equality Act of 2010 have contributed to promote an ‘inclusive’ approach to religion pluralism, granting access to spiritual assistance and equal treatment among prison inmates. However, it is worth to consider if a State-centred management of religious diversity is a sustainable choice before the growing judicial litigation related to prisoners’ freedom of worship.

Download in PDF format